Follow
Share

My husband has dementia and opens passengers front door while driving.
putting him in back seat is demeaning as an adult.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Placing him in the back seat is NOT demeaning.
It is a safety measure.
He opens the car door. This is not only dangerous for him but for other cars on the road.
And will he stop at opening the door, when will he grab the steering wheel?
And as far as I know if the car is running and the car is in PARK the doors will not unlock UNLESS they are unlocked by pressing the LOCK button or toggle. If he is doing that then he should NOT be in the front.

When you ride in a cab...you are in the backseat.
Most of the time in a Ride Share you are in the backseat.
The safest place is the backseat.

You need to change your frame of mind on this. As the driver, responsible for the safety of the people in the car you set the rules.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Grandma1954 Jan 26, 2024
oops..I think I meant if the car is in gear..not Park.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
I just checked out my car (11yrs old) and my DHs (14 yrs old) and neither of them can you opened the door once the car is in gear. Only when its put in park will the doors open. Child restraint is so they can not get out until car is opened from the outside. There is a button for putting down the window but none to unlock the door. All doors and windows can be controlled by the driver. We have GM products.

Yes, leave him in the back. Safer if in an accident and no likelihood of him grabbing the steering will,
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

find an excuse to put him in the back seat Who says it is demeaning? Think "Driving Miss Daisy"
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 23, 2024
Love that movie!
(0)
Report
Read the manual of your vehicle and it will tell you where the safety lock is located.

BTW, you should not think of your husband sitting in the backseat of your vehicle as being “demeaning”; you should think of it that it’s for his safety.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Backseat is not demeaning. Safety should be your first priority. The backseat is the safest area.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Try Honda. My 2006 Honda Element has childproof front seat locks.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Kmkinne: In my car, the driver controls the locks. If your auto does not, it's safer for him to sit in the back seat, albeit "demeaning."
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Demeaning as it is, there's no better place to be! A deployment of an airbag is very fatal in the elderly! Their frail bodies can't handle the impact. Not only is there impact of a crash but the airbag forces pressure against the body. Safe than sorry. That's when people should notice the dents and dings on the vehicle and take away the keys. Dr's recommend it.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

You can also be sneaky and once he’s secured in the car before taking off, press the automatic lock which locks all doors when he’s in the front seat. Once you’ve arrived at your destination, unlock your door, get out, immediately lock the door again (with him still in the car), go around to his side, unlock all doors and help him get out. Hope that is helpful!
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Hmmm I have a 2005 Chev truck and a 2013 Toyota I can lock all with a button. If in doubt check your owners manual or just drive to dealer of brand and I bet they will show you. You may even be able to go on line to YouTube and ask that question for your model and yo may see videos. Good luck
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I have been having my husband ride in the back seat for at least a year now. Mostly it seems more comfortable. He doesn't really pay attention to the view and even if I point something out to him, by the time his mind processes it and he turns, we are long past it. Dementia is not fun. He seems to be fine with riding back there, I find it more comfortable for me knowing he is there and if he wants to close his eyes, so much the better. I think the "demeaning" part is perhaps your perception and not one he would have in his state of mind.

Given how anxiety can get to those with dementia, riding up front where they can see cars in front, brake lights and cars coming towards them in the oncoming lane(s), might be fraught with more problems than help. And if the driver has to make sudden moves or hit the brakes, it might be better if it isn't all seen by the passenger. Not demeaning - more like taking their condition into account and finding ways to make their travel as free of anxiety possibilities as possible.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Safety comes first.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

BACK SEAT if equipped with child lock is the answer. Ask traffic enforcement. You could be responsible for an accident.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I have found that Seatbelt Lock Covers do help. They don't keep the passenger from trying to open the door (the incentive for their use) or from trying to interfere with the driver (fortunately, a problem I've not yet encountered) but DO keep him securely fastened in the seat until I unlock the seatbelt. Even if the door were opened, it would be unlikely that the passenger could actually make a dive to exit....Word of caution - there are different sizes - I had to order 3 before I got one to fit - fortunately, they're cheap...
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I personally choose the passenger rear seat as safest so he can't reach the steering wheel. That said, many cars can have child lock features activated on the front passenger door by the dealers. There is usually no mention of this in the owner's manual. Check with a dealer for your make of car.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
AlvaDeer Jan 21, 2024
And again. Adult harnesses. On Amazon. Very safe and secure.
(3)
Report
My 2009 Prius has a child lock on the front passenger side.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

I know my car locks all doors when its put into drive. In my DHs car I can't get out until he outs the car in park. Not sure about mine but both are GMCs so probably the same thing.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Look up "adult car safety harness" on your favorite search engine.
There are many devices out there that are assistive devices for safety of special needs folks.
These harnesses specifically for car travel run about 100.00 to 150.00.
They range from safety needs such as you mention to positional safety for those impaired from CVA, and etc.

Good luck.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

The whole dementia experience is demeaning. While driving home from a walk at a local park, my wife opened the passenger car door and tried to jump out. I quickly grabbed the seat belt to keep her from getting out. She was delusional and thought I was going to hurt her. She struggled to jump out, I struggled to keep her in. Without going into detail, the 20 minute drive home was hair raising. After that experience, I piled some large books in the front passenger seat and would ask her to please sit in the back because I didn’t want to move all those books. I also engaged the child proof locks in the back. Demeaning or not, it’s about their safety and your sanity. That was the experience that put me over the top. The next week she was in MC.
Helpful Answer (20)
Report
geddyupgo Jan 22, 2024
Oh my. That must have been so frightening. Glad you are both safe!!
(2)
Report
My car can lock ALL the doors. The control is on the driver’s door, just one of all the lock options. It stops anyone getting out, and also anyone getting in (eg a bad person accessing when the car is stopped). Mine is just a small Hyundai hatch. Check what controls you actually have, there may be more useful options than you are aware of.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
TopsailJanet Jan 20, 2024
My Subaru Legacy is the same, as are many other cars. I think the back seat is safer in regard to grabbing the wheel, though. I don’t think the back seat is demeaning, I put mom in the front seat because it is easier to get in or out of and she is not a danger in that way.
(7)
Report
The back seat may seem demeaning to you, but it is the most safe. It also keeps them away from the controls of the car. Remember, unexpected behaviors in a car can be deadly.
Helpful Answer (14)
Report

When dementia has regressed an adult back into a toddler who has to be secured with child locks in a car, put them in the backseat. When a person has gotten to this point it really isn't safe to treat them like adults anymore.

Safety first. Back seat. I was a caregiver for 25 years. Anytime I had to take a client with dementia in my car they always sat in the backseat whether they wanted to or not. This was a condition of travelling in my car. It was either the backseat, or we don't go.
Helpful Answer (21)
Report

The back seat is "demeaning"? It depends how you look at it.

My mother the Queen loved riding in the back seat of the car, behind my father the driver.....she felt his body would be a nice buffer for HER should they get in a car accident. 😑

My husband has a 2016 Nissan Rogue.....all the doors stay locked automatically while the car is in motion.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

The back seat is not demeaning. When someone becomes very sick as he is accommodations must be made for safety.

Consider riding in the back seat with him and hiring or asking someone else to drive you.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

There’s nothing demeaning about riding in the back. He doesn’t need to be anywhere near the steering wheel.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report
BurntCaregiver Jan 16, 2024
Safety first at all times.
(6)
Report
My Aunt with dementia used to sit in the front passenger seat until one day when she decided to grab the wheel and try to turn it while we were driving on the highway. And she used to roll down the window and scream HELP! at passing cars. So, lock the windows as well.

The back seat is the safest option.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report

How very dangerous for both you and him that he's opening the car door while driving. And how silly that you think that putting him in the back seat and keeping you both safe is "demeaning."
Just pretend that you are his personal chauffeur like in the movie Driving Miss Daisy, or in your case it would be Driving Mr.(fill in the blank).
Either that or just don't take him anywhere anymore. Or perhaps it's getting to be time to think about having him placed in a memory care facility, where he will be kept safe and you can get back to just being his wife and advocate.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
Geaton777 Jan 16, 2024
Factoids du jour:

"Shotgun" (front passenger side) is called such from the days when the Wells Fargo stagecoach used to deliver money and mail. There were always highway robbers to watch out for.

The back passenger side is the "Presidential seat" so that the VIP can easily see and talk to the driver (and visa versa).

Treat the hubs like a VIP.
(16)
Report
Not sure how the back seat is demeaning. It's likely safer than the front seat. Adults ride in the backseat of cars all the time, including (but not limited to) limos.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I don't get the demeaning part, his brain is broken, safety first. Sounds like it is an embarrassment to you. Many adults ride in the back seat.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report

Safety first. He should ride in the back seat for all the reasons the posters gave. If he has dementia he has no perception of being demeaned anyway.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter