Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
I'm guessing that you currently live in your mother's home. There's nothing wrong with wanting your own place and some privacy, and if that's where your heart is, then you should go have those things. Your mom could sell her home and use any profits to pay for her new, smaller, one-level home or ground-floor apartment. Does she have a friend who'd like to live with her in her new home, and pay rent (and hopefully uses a computer!)? If not, you and your brother could check in with her every day, and do the occasional computer-related tasks on weekends for her. There's nothing wrong with moving away. After all, your brother did it, didn't he? If he feels badly about you moving on, is he willing to move in with her or have her share his home? If he's not willing to do it, then he shouldn't be upset with your choice, either.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

If your mother loves you she should not want you to give up your life for her. I would never want that for my son. You should live on your own and find a wonderful relationship if you can. It isn’t an all or nothing proposition. Your mother can live on her own and you can still visit or take her out and enjoy each other. She can hopefully find social activities herself and when and if the time comes she may need assisted living that is a great option. My mom has Alzheimer’s and has been in assisted living 2.5 years. She lived with my brother and wife for 2 years prior but they just couldn’t be with her all the time. I feel no guilt. I feel bad that she is in perfect physical shape as her brilliant mind disappears. She is 90 and will probably live to 100 but with no memory. It’s very sad. She would not want to live this way and she seems to understand and apologizes for being a burden. She is not a burden to me since she’s receiving excellent care but it is very depressing. Don’t let anyone guilt you into living with her, whether it’s your brother or others on this site. I wish you well.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Therefore a man leaves his father and his mother and clings to his wife, and they become one flesh. Put another way, a wife leaves her mother and her father, and clings to her husband. Either way to me it means to look first to the life God has given you before all else.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

No you do not "owe it to her" or need to live with her. From what you have said in posts here the two of you do not get on well. You have dogs, she doesn't like them and so on.Best to stay apart and keep the peace. You are entitled to your own life separate from her.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

True, my children did not ask to be born but neither did I & neither did my parents, grandparents, & so on.
When did people become so callous & so self-centered??
We were not put on this earth to only think about ourselves!!
All groups of caring humans do anything they can for one another-no matter who they are. My husband & I were fortunate enough to give of our time, our strength, financial help to our children, to both of our parents, inlaws, friends/neighbors. Some lived w/us, some we spent many years with. We are not rich by any means. In fact, my first paying job was getting paid for picking cotton @8 yrs old.
We never turned our backs on anyone- especially our parents!!!
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

DoggieMom86: Prayers sent.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Look at HUD subsidized apartments for the elderly. She would pay 30% of her monthly income. We do not owe our parents anything but respect and to make sure they are safe, have food and healthcare. It is not our job to make them happy. Took me two years of counseling to learn that!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Thank you to all the responders for putting things in perspective for me. Mom and I never had a close relationship despite me being the only daughter. I am riddled with guilt and a sense of obligation even though I have (2) brothers that do nothing. Mom decided she wanted to live with me and like an idiot savant I agreed - I had no idea what I was signing up for other than giving her a place to live - I set up a studio suite in my home. I feel trapped and resentful. I have no life and all I want to do is run away. And yes, apparently her plan for her future was ME.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

Thank you to all the responders for putting things in perspective for me. Mom and I never had a close relationship despite me being the only daughter. I am riddled with guilt and a sense of obligation even though I have (2) brothers that do nothing. Mom decided she wanted to live with me and like an idiot savant I agreed - I had no idea what I was signing up for other than giving her a place to live - I set up a studio suite in my home. I feel trapped and resentful. I have no life and all I want to do is run away. And yes, apparently her plan for her future was ME.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
JeanLouise Feb 2025
Trapped, resentful and want to run away. That’s a daily mantra for me. Best of luck to you; enjoy your life
(7)
Report
See 1 more reply
I am almost 76, and I am caring for my 96-year-old blind, deaf and back-pained mother. I am also a mother and grandmother, who would love to have the time to spend with them. As long as your mother is not demented, then she can care for herself and do for herself. It is still her own responsibility to live her own life. If I can (and I have had two back operations and a shoulder replaced) take care of my mother, your mother can take care of herself. As far as what are we obligated to our parents. I think it is what we are capable of (physically, emotionally, financially), and that is very personal. Some moralists may not agree, but neither should they judge. My mother lived with us for a while, but it was very hard, very stressful, and dangerous to all of our physical health. She then moved to an assisted living, but we are now dealing with issues that are going to require skilled nursing. We know she will hate it, we know she will not deal well with it, and we know she will resent us and blame us. But remember, we have no control over aging. We are not expert care givers. We, sometimes, can make the situation worse because our dementia parents seem to have more "problems" when we are around them. It is like when a child skins their knee, they only cry harder around their parents. Now is the time for your mother to start doing something about her really old age years and try to think prepare for them realistically because of her finances. Science and medicine have made the quantity of years of life much longer but has not made the quality that much better. After care for my mother, I do NOT want to put my children through what we are going through, nor do I want to have the quality of life my mother is now suffering.
Helpful Answer (15)
Report
SID2020 Jul 15, 2025
So helpful thank you.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
I currently live in a rented home with the lease in my name. I pay the rent and utility. My mom helps with groceries and some of the bills. My mother was married once to my brother, well half-brother’s father. Her ex-husband is deceased. She received some money from him with Social Security. She did not marry my father (long story). My mom has never owned a home, she’s rented her whole life.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Countrygal44 Feb 2025
Have you heard of that. Medicaid? Most care facilities work with people needing to be in a care home and get the Medicaid so everything is paid for.
(0)
Report
My immediate thought is: why are you asking the question "Do I owe it to her" -
I feel there is another question here, but not sure what it is.
- How you feel about yourself
- How you feel about making a decision to move on in your life - and perhaps you feel you do not deserve to do so
- Feeling torn / guilty?

You initially appear to be very clear on what you want in your life and pursuits moving foward. If I were you, I would do some soul searching and figure how what you want, what is in your way of pursuing what you say you want, assess how you are feeling.

No one can make these decisions for you.
In some ways, you can try it out and see how your mom functions living alone.
I wonder: was she able to live alone before - when you two were living together? If not, how much support / guidance / care did you provide to her when you lived together? She won't have that level of support living alone. Does this concern you or cause you to second guess yourself?

I question how much personal power you are giving to your brother since you quote his words / what he states. What is your relationship with him? As a second thought - why doesn't your brother live with your mom ... if he is so concerned about her ... and thinking it is your responsibility (?) ... if I got this right.

Are you sure your mom can manage on her own living alone?
Is this the reason or one reason you are questioning your decisions to move forward in your own life.

I can only (think to) ask the questions that you need to ask yourself. Often we don't know what the 'best' route is when making decisions about our parents' care as they age. We do the best we can in any given moment ... we regroup as we need to.

Personally, if you and your brother can manage the finances to get your mom the (apartment) care she needs, I'd give it a try - AS - I am a firm believer in a younger person (or not) pursuing their own life pursuits - education, relationship, job/work. You deserve to be happy, too. Do not forget that.

Gena / Touch Matters
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
DoggieMom86 Feb 2025
She lived with my brother and his wife before I moved back, I do feel bad about wanting to live my own life as I don’t want her to feel lonely or abandoned, I love my mom but of course we have differing opinions on things. I guess I feel bad she doesn’t have her own friends and a significant other.
(0)
Report
In my opinion, if you have a baby, that's on you. It's not on the baby.

When it comes to the question of whether children "owe" their parents, I like to remember Sidney Poiter's monologue in Guess Who's Coming to Dinner. He is speaking to his father, who has just told him he owes him for all the years he had to carry a mail bag to take care of him.

"You tell me what rights I've got or haven't got, and what I owe to you for what you've done for me. Let me tell you something. I owe you nothing! If you carried that bag a million miles, you did what you were supposed to do! Because you brought me into this world. And from that day you owed me everything you could ever do for me like I will owe my son if I ever have another. But you don't own me!"
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

I would say that if she is physically and mentally able to live by herself, she should be able to do so. DON'T feel guilty for needing your own space. Moving her in with you might cause her to develop learned abilities to not know how to do lots of things she currently knows how to do. (I know there is a better way to put that, but I had a brain fart).

Living by herself, she will be able to stay independent longer by sheer necessity. I call my mom (87) every night, and sometimes I conference her in if I need to help her with medical things (like getting yearly re-approved for prescriptions that require that, etc), but she schedules her own paratransit rides (to see her doctors), and walks 4,500 steps or more every day she doesn't have a doctor's visit. I also have her call me when she is in with the doctor, so I know what's going on. But other than that, she does her own thing. I live 2 1/2 hours from her and try to visit every other weekend, depending on if I have a cold or if there is snow. So far so good.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

No, you are not crazy and you don't owe it to your mother to continue living with her.
Your Mom is encouraging you to be independent, by saying she does not want to live with you or your brother and wants her own studio apartment.
My guess is that you feel guilty because she lived with your brother for a while and now it's "your turn"? There is nothing to feel guilty about. Every parent should push their child from the nest so she can fly.
I'm curious as to why your Mom moved in with your brother? Was it upon the death of your step-father? If so, your brother wasn't helping in the long run by not having a plan for your Mom to regain her independence. Is your Mom healthy both physically and mentally? Sounds like she is, but she is just lonely and not used to living alone.
The suggestion of a subsidized senior apartment is something to be looked into.
Start getting your Mom involved in social activities. The local senior center may have things she is interested in. Many YMCAs have free admission under Medicare's Silver Sneakers program for those 65 and older. Once she is active again, she will build confidence in herself.
Good luck.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

im sorry you feelobligated to stay in town and have your mother live with you. It is great if you and your brother each can contribute $300 each month with her expenses.. as she gets older, there could be more expenses. We live in an assisted living and just sold our home which wil pay for a couple more years.. our 3 kids live in the same town as we do. When we need medical help or anything mainly our daughter takes care of the things we need, if it gets too busy her brothers also help when needed. . We do pay our daughter a nice wage for all the care that she gives us.. we do you feel that fair isn’t always equal. Good luck it is a hard decision.. I didn’t want any of our children to resent having to take care of us. I wanted it to be a choice..,
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

No you should not feel guilt. Since your Mom seems to very low income there are lots of senior low income apartments. She can also apply for section 8 vouchers. If you go to housing on aging, seniors center or welfare they should be able to direct you in finding those low income senior housing. The problem is sometimes the wait time is long. You may also consider also having your Mom apply in the city or state where you are moving, so if a place comes available she could move closer to you, yet still be independent. Your Mom is still young so making arrangements now for future is the best solution. If she needs to move to a studio in the interim while waiting for senior low income apartments you and your brother may have to supplement that cost. Make sure when you send a check or direct deposit note down it’s Rent Payment or Rent Assistance.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter