Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
1 2 3
As a Catholic I don’t know where you got the idea that you need to force fluids on a dying woman. This is the dying process as it is supposed to be.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

I’m not sure thats true and the church. Sounds like your mom is at the end of her life. Please pray and be with her as much as you can to say goodbye.

I'm not sure why hospice won’t take her in, that’s what they do. Please speak with hospice again. Also, speak with your church to explain what’s going on.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

as one dies s/he does not require nourishment or fluids. giving her fluids will only prolong the inevitable and perhaps make death more painful for her.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Did the facility state she still wants to drink and eat? If so, she can, but only the amount she can take,

I worked with our local Catholic hospital providing hospice, and it is the best care for hospice. When a person can no longer take water, it is sign they are coming to the end stage and forcing water is against standards of care.

My father went into hospice and having power of attorney, I wanted him hydrated in a Catholic hospital, himself a devout Catholic. He developed bronchial pneumonia. The staff told me they had to clear his lungs twice that day causing him to suffer. I cried knowing he would be leaving soon.

He had peace and comfort.

The tradition of Catholic instituted hospice goes back almost 2,000 years.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Debstarr53 Aug 2022
Too bad whoever laid this guilt trip on her, did not know this.
(4)
Report
The Catholic Church knows nothing about the dying process. The hospice people should fully inform you about the process and where your loved one is in that process. Part is to stop intake, as the body shuts down. You are not “withholding” fluids, her body is not taking them. Indeed, forcing those fluids might well distress her.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Breezy23 Aug 2022
The Catholic church is not the problem here, and your attack on the OP for asking for guidance within her religious beliefs is not helpful. The Catholic church indeed does know a lot about the dying process, the OP does not understand that through the dying process the person does not desire food or drink, and the church understands this. The OP is incorrectly assuming that withholding fluids is wrong however it is not in the eyes of the church unless the intent is for a reason to deliberately kill someone. The church can and does support the natural process. The OP needs to consult their priest for guidance and the hospital and nursing home will and can offer hospice advice, and how to get it. The OP can consult with the social worker for help with that.
(5)
Report
See 1 more reply
There's a difference between withholding fluids and not forcing fluids. Your mother's body is telling her it's time to pass and it doesn't want any more fluids. When the church tells you not to withhold fluids, it doesn't mean force her to take fluids her body cannot process.

When my mother was in the hospital before her death, at the end stage of a long illness, she stopped eating. The hospital continued to bring her meals, but they didn't attempt to make her eat. Food was not withheld, but it was also not forced.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

I can understand the desire to look for ways to artifically extend her life but it does sound like she is in the process of dying. Hospice is so good about preparing families to say good bye and helping to assist your loved one in being comfortable to the fullest extent possible. You can initiate fluids by giving her small ice chunks or sips of water. Her body will tell her when to stop taking fluids. Hospice can help you identify that time. I am not sure what the Catholic Church has to do with the dying process. No church can change the dying process. Its the course of dying that the person will eventually stop eating and drinking. You are not "sinning" by accepting this. I would hope that the family's goal would be to help her go through these processes with dignity keeping her as comfortable as possible.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

You said it all in your first sentence: "My mom is in an adult home, 97 yrs old and dying."

That means she needs hospice. It doesn't matter where she lives. Hospice will come to her, and work with the adult home to provide the end-of-life care she needs and deserves. I think you're doing your mom a disservice by waiting. Here's an article on this same website on this very topic.

https://www.agingcare.com/articles/family-wait-too-long-call-hospice-152891.htm
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

I recently learned about a service called end-of-life doula. Just like a birth doula serves a mom and family through the natural birthing process, an end-of-life doula serves a person and their family through the natural dying process. I have no idea of the cost, but if affordable I think I would like to have that service when my time comes. It is all about respecting the loved ones wishes while you keep them comfortable.

https://inelda.org/
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Perhaps you should consult the "Catholic Church" that set these rules in place and ask them to take her. Where do all the dying Catholics go to abide by their rules?

Perhaps different Hospices offer different approaches?

Perhaps Adult Protective services can place her appropriately?
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
Debstarr53 Aug 2022
Totally agree with you. If the "Catholic Church" sets the rules, let them do the caretaking and provide the necessary options. Great comment, short and to the point.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
Read the posts in response to yours, there is a wealth of knowledge. Whoever informed you before has given you some wrong information. Please call her priest to give her last rites, and I’m sorry for your loss.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Hospice knows what they are doing, sounds like the Catholic guilt tripper does not.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

I found out why when my father was dying. Parts of the body shut down one by one. One of the last ones is the throat fails to swallow. To try and give fluids can cause the person to get fluid in their lungs and that's how many people end up back in the hospital with pneumonia.
My dad refused liquid, and one his kidneys were going, his body was unable to process it. He was "fasting" naturally. He was able to see angels and God was able to prepare him, which I think is very, very scriptural.
I think what that particular branch of the church means is to "offer" drink. Of course you have compassion. But once the body is ready to go, your loved one will refuse, and that is compassionate. Your loved one knows what they need, you offer it, but if they refuse, you honor it. Honoring our parents is also scriptural.
that's why I'm not catholic. They have so many rules that aren't scripture based, but tradition. I believe in surrendering to the Lord and following His lead. He is the one who is Lord over life and death, and in the end, it's between you, your loved one and the Lord.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
Breezy23 Aug 2022
Please do not bash one religion over another. Clearly you are not an expert on or know the Catholic religion and what you perceive to be "rules" The best the OP can do is to consult her own priest for guidance in this matter. When people seek help is certainly is not helpful to declare "that is why I'm not Catholic" because the OP and her mother are and you are thus critical of their beliefs, not what the OP needs at this time. Certainly your remark is not "spiritual "
(6)
Report
See 1 more reply
So, the hospital sent your mother back to the adult home with a dx of renal insufficiency meaning the kidneys are not functioning properly. Did the hospital tell which stage she is in? Is she in the end stage of her kidney disease? If she is actively dying, palliative care could have been called in to give her some sort of treatment and to alleviate discomfort during the dying process. A doctor would make this call. Did someone tell you that your mom is in the process at this point? Dialysis is out of the question for you, but have you talked this over with a physician?
I'm not sure what the Catholic Church's stance is about withholding food or drink from a person. I would presume that since someone is not in the dying process, they should be offered something to eat or drink. It sounds like toxins are building up in your mother's bloodstream at this point. I would talk with the attending physician to see if there is anything else that can be done at this point to ease her suffering if she is in any discomfort.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Dear Vacayassist, So, sorry your mother is dying. I worked for decades in a hospital and discussed this issue with hospice staff many times. My own dearly loved mother-in-law and mother both went through this.

Yes, do offer your mother fluids as you desire. However, in the last stages of dying the need to eat and drink diminishes. This is not painful for them. Providing food and nutrition will not reverse the dying and hospice research now knows that using artificial means to hydrate and feed can cause harm. The need for fluids is tied into the amount of calories consumed. With the lack of appetite and almost no food eaten (part of the dying process), your mother needs very little fluid. So yes comfort her. Moisten her mouth and give her sips as the nursing staff show you how. Talk to her and tell her you love her. May you find comfort at this time.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report

If she's dying Hospice should be called in. I am confused as to why this hasn't been done already. I believe you are misinterpreting the Catholic Church. I would call the priest at your mom’s church and talk to him about it. Also, if someone is dying they aren't going to want food or water. You can offer but more than likely they won't want it. They are are going through a natural process.
Helpful Answer (12)
Report
Ella2021 Aug 2022
Yes, Hospice has chaplains. I think most people's minds are going in so many different directions that it never occurs to them to ask. And they can give council because they see so much.
(2)
Report
Praying for you and your family to have peace during this difficult time.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I’m sorry your mother is hurting and you’re losing her. Do you think she’ll eat hydration candies? They’re made for people with dementia or Alzheimer’s, but 95% water and real cute for the elder’s interest. If you like ‘em, I suggest you order because they were just sold out.

https://www.jellydrops.us/
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Hospice care.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

So sorry you’re going through a difficult period. Never stop asking questions and your solution will be found. Not sure if they’re able to swallow at al but, If they are able to try the baby dropper and a few drops of water periodically ( just enough to moisten their mouth that should reduce chance of chocking) can even use it for a little puréed baby foods possibly. Sending prayers 💕
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Prayers for your dear sweet mother & all of your family! Such a difficult time! I wanted to make a mention you may be incorrect about what the Catholic Church teaches in regards to end of life for a “non-dying person” vs. a “dying” person. Your dear mother seems to be the latter & is at end stage of life from renal insufficiency no matter if she’s given hydration & nutrition. I believe in this case, the Church recognizes that artificial hydration and/or nutrition should not be pursued when it is not able to “accomplish its proper finality.” When the dying process cannot be reversed with nutrition or hydration or is too burdensome for the person. Things can get confusing with difficult cases in our quest to preserve life at all stages. I know our Catholic faith is misunderstood at times but rules are in place to preserve life in general. God has your Mother in the palm of his hand, & knows you are doing your best for her. Hospice in for comfort care is wonderful & you should not worry. Consult with your Pastor if you are concerned, review the Catechism, & I know your discernment in the matter will be divinely sent to you. Giving her love, all of your goodness, & praying the Divine Mercy Chaplet over her will bring peace to her & graces to you beautiful person. Peace of Christ be with you!
Helpful Answer (13)
Report
MBJB77 Aug 2022
Amen!
(2)
Report
vacayassist: The church and medical doctors are two separate entities. Perhaps your mother requires hospice now.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
TeethGrinder65 Sep 2022
There is Catholic hospice, and here's what they say: "We provide medically assisted food and water, which we do not equate with medical care but with basic nourishment, and we continue to do so unless the food and water cannot be assimilated or unless the burden of providing this nourishment outweighs the benefit of it."
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
This must be so difficult. I am Catholic, Dad was not. Hospice guided me on the non eating/non drinking issue.

it is a normal physiological process when dying and the hospice nurse told me that it was normal and he was not suffering.

Dad died a peaceful death on September 28th. It has been hard to deal with the eating issues with both of my parents but I trust the physiological process.

make sure you access all the support you have available but as people come to the end of life it becomes less about religious beliefs and more about comfort care
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

The answer given by SherryS was the most accurate describing the difference between dying and non-dying. I found out what she was talking about when my father was dying. Different parts of the body shut down one by one. One of the last ones is the throat fails to swallow. To try and give fluids can cause the person to get fluid in their lungs and that's how many people end up back in the hospital with pneumonia. That made me feel better because I got very upset that they would not continue giving him fluids.
Once they tell you that your parent is "active", at that point hospice comes in. And they do have Chaplains. You are in a very emotional place and it is the hardest thing you will ever have to do. Most of us have no idea what Hospice can do until we need them. So glad you have this forum to ask people to help.
My dad refused liquid, and once his kidneys were going, his body was unable to process it. He was "fasting" naturally. He was able to see angels and God was able to prepare him.
I think what the church means is to "offer" drink if a person is thirsty. You have compassion and you love your parent and want what's best. But once the body is ready to go, your loved one will refuse because their body is in a natural state, and that is compassionate to let them rest. Your loved one knows what they need, you offer it, but if they refuse, you honor it. Her body knows.
Check with your pastor or talk with a Chaplain. They can help you when your mind is going in many different directions. He is the one who is Lord over life and death, and in the end, it's between you, your loved one and the Lord. I pray you have a peace that passes all understanding and that you will rest in knowing that this isn't all there is, and what is to come is so much better and you will see her again. Sit beside her and walk her home. God bless you. You are loved and many hearts go out to you.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

It’s sad when our loved ones are at end of life. Be with her as much as you can. I just went through this with a friend. The only thing she would take was a little milkshake on a spoon. Be really careful about her chocking. Plenty of fluids were available to her, she just didn’t want to drink them. She’s fortunate to have you looking out for her. I hope that I live as long without to much suffering.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

IV Hydration Multiplier is a powder available online at Amazon as a 16-packet in different flavors and adds needed minerals, electrolytes, etc, similar to Pedialite, etc; though I believe this to be a product with better sodium/sugar balance. My 94-year old mother with chronic UTI’s and dehydration, likes each the grape flavor (mixed into grape juice) and strawberry (mixed into lemonade or sprite), It increases her fluid intake without needing to ‘drink daily difficult needed amounts.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Kathleen105 Sep 2022
I take it myself. Escellent.
(1)
Report
About 15 years ago, my father and sister were both dying from different medical conditions - my adult sister was in her home and my father was in a nursing home. I sought out advice from our Catholic parish and the end-of-life materials they provided me were immensely helpful. I read the materials and attended a live seminar that the church offered at different parishes where attendees could ask questions. Force feeding for food or fluids was never endorsed or recommended by the Catholic Church. Death is a natural process and with it comes certain indicators such as sleeping more and eating and drinking less. We were fortunate that the hospice agency we selected also understood our anguish and ambivalence re our loved ones' deteriorating conditions. Please reach out to your diocesan office and ask them for education re end-of-life decisions. You are not alone - many of us have walked in your shoes. Our prayers are with you.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

You agree, she is dying. Hospice does not intervene with fluids. If under hospice they will make her comfortable and hospice will give you "suggestions" You will have your mothers need when Hospice is in charge. You will have "peace" of mind.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
TeethGrinder65 Sep 2022
Hospice is fine with food and fluids unless they're making the patient sicker (choking, inability to swallow, pain, inability to process fluids because of kidney failure). You can have food and water till the day you die if you're able to take it. Most people don't. They start shutting down before this, and forcing food and water on them causes more pain and physical distress.
(3)
Report
Contact someone in a Catholic Hospice and speak to a priest. They will guide you.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Just want to clarify here (as a Catholic and a hospice volunteer). Fluids CAN be withheld if they're making the patient sicker (like, she's unable to process the water because of her kidney failure, and the fluid will just build up, essentially drowning her).
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
AlvaDeer Sep 2022
amen
(2)
Report
1 2 3
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter