Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
5 6 7 8 9
I hope everyone understands that I am learning A LOT from your brilliant advice and I do say NO that’s why she becomes upset and still does - so I just give in. Now I need help with this - how the heck are we going to tell them that we’re going to Europe soon without them to find a central base to live in so we will be able to start our retirement? I know I sound so childish.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
Saying, “No!” has to be consistent. You can’t say, “No!” one minute and then give in and cater to her whims the next minute. How is your mom supposed to take you seriously if you flip flop like that?

As for you’re going to Europe, you buy your tickets, pack your bags, say goodbye with a huge smile 😃 on your face and then fly off into the wild, blue yonder! Simple! That is a no brainer!

Everyone should have problems this easy to fix. Do you even realize how fortunate you are to be able to retire comfortably in Europe?

Max,

Start being extra grateful for what you do have in your life. You have so much to look forward to.

Don’t take your health for granted. Your health is everything!

Live YOUR best life with your husband. Forget about what went wrong up to now. Everyone that is breathing has had their share of problems in their lives. You don’t have to be stuck in misery.

Learn to place everything in the proper perspective. Let the past go. It’s over. Stop holding on. You’re not being brave or even doing the right thing by continuing to hold on. It didn’t work years ago and it isn’t working now, nor will it ever work. So. once and for all, let go and enjoy your life.

One thing that my therapist said to me was that I had more years behind me than ahead, so stop wasting time. He was right! You have wasted a ton of time and money. Put an end to it and send us all photos of your favorite places in Europe!
(2)
Report
Max;

WHEN she becomes upset, LEAVE the premises.

Let her understand by your ACTIONS (not your words) that you will not continue to be her slave.

If you give in every time she gets upset, you are TELLING her that getting upset works as a tool of manipulation.

Do you give your dog food every time he yaps? No, of course not.

STOP reinforcing her bad behavior.

Stop kowtowing to her demands.

Say "NO" and mean it. The way you mean it is by leaving.

PLEASE consider getting a hotel room.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
maximus1 Jan 2023
Barb, great idea, but if I go to a hotel my mom will be screaming and arguing with us. I can’t leave on horrific terms like that. When I return home I’ll be reaching out for professional help. This is crazy, I know -how can a 92 year old be that controlling!
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
As to telling your parents that you're going to retire to Europe:

"Mom, Dad, we are very excited. We are going to retire to Europe next year".

Mom: "What about us, What are your plans for us? Your just going to abandon us, aren't you. (weeping ensues).

"Mom, you and dad are going to hire a geriatric care manager who will find you a nice retirement community so you can have a life separate from ours."

(mom weeps and throws a tantrum)

You continue packing.

DON'T respond to this balderdash. Enough is enough.

You sound childish (to your own ears) because your mom never encouraged you to live your own life. She kept you tied to her so she could be guaranteed HER freedom. She is a supremely selfish person.

At least that's how it sounds to me, despite your telling us how wonderful she is.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
You know, I could be wrong. We aren’t always correct when we assume things, but I wonder if Max is subconsciously trying to recreate the ‘perfect’ family that she feels that she was cheated out of.

Oh my gosh, no one on this wide green earth has ever had a ‘perfect’ family 100 percent of the time.

When we see others who appear to have great lives, we have no idea what they have endured behind closed doors.

I have a couple of friends that have spent time at a women’s shelter for months after being in abusive relationships. Ha! They were both married to very successful men that abused them horribly.

No one would ever suspect this if they saw them now. My point is that we all have our own stories to tell.
(3)
Report
Let her be mad. Saying no will get easier once you start doing it. My Mom was the type to stomp around with a mad face and use the silent treatment when I was a kid. I tell you what it is very easy to ignore that type of behavior when you’re at your own home!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

Let her get upset, just don't react to it. She gets upset because it has always gotten her results.

My father would say the same thing if I went on vacation "who is going to take care of me" (this was when he was capable of living on his own). I told him that was his responsibility to figure out. I wasn't his caretaker, I was his daughter who helped him out because he didn't drive. It was not my job to find him another daughter to fill in for me.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

As a former worry wort...STOP WORRYING

Why do you worry so much about what your parents think. That was OK as a child but you are now an adult on the verge of retiring. Your going to Europe alone because they can no longer travel, Mom needs too much help. And who would be providing that help. How can it be a vacation when you have to take care of someone the whole time. You tell Mom your going to Europe the day before you leave. YOU ARE ENTITLED TO HAVE A VACATION ALONE WITH YOUR HUSBAND. Call it a second honeymoon.

I really think u and DH should stay in a motel on Friday night. Say ur goodbyes then. Saturday you and DH have a nice breakfast together and home you go. Seems your Dad is very capable of caring for Mom. That is his job. Just like your job is being there for your husband. When Mom asks you when your coming back, say you have no idea. You have already given her over 2 months of your life.

You put too much stress on yourself. You have already had a serious health episode. Stress is not good for cancer. I would think this scare would have made you realize that you need to live your life for you. You and DH should make memories together. Your going into a new phase in you life. You have given enough of your life to your parents. Your Mom should be praising God that she still has a daughter. Maybe that is what you need to tell her. "Mom having cancer made me realize I have given too much of my life to you. So now DH is retiring, we will be doing a lot more just us"

When she asks about Dads birthday, just say after spending over 2 months with them, u can't possibly come back in less than a month. Maybe have a birthday party Friday with cake. You seem to worry about her reactions. So she gets upset, that is not your fault.

When saying No, you are not responsible for the reaction you get. You are not responsible for how your Mom eats. She knows she isn't suppose to have salt but she eats it. Thats between her, Dad and her doctor. When your all packed up and ready to leave you give them both a hug and a kiss on the cheek and tell them you will see them when u see them.

My MIL chose to live in Fla at 68 yrs old. It was a 16 hr drive for us. We had two kids. One 11 the other 3. You know how much we went down, 1x a year until we retired. Then it was 2x a year. Once around Summer the other Thanksgiving. I spent Christmas with my girls and grands.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
I love that you say that you are a ‘former’ worry wart. People can stop worrying if they change their focus.

I know someone who struggles with constant worry and I limit my time around her because I feel so drained after being with her.

When I tell her that she has to stop worrying excessively over trivial issues, she says that she has been this way all of her life.

I have found that 99 percent of the things that most people worry about never even come to pass. Some people have huge issues with anxiety. It’s sad.
(1)
Report
Barb, great idea, but if I go to a hotel my mom will be screaming and arguing with us. I can’t leave on horrific terms like that. When I return home I’ll be reaching out for professional help. This is crazy, I know -how can a 92 year old be that controlling?!
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
lealonnie1 Jan 2023
The real question is, how can a 60 year old allow herself to be that controlled by a 92 year old parent?
(4)
Report
See 3 more replies
If you can't stand for your mom to scream, then I have nothing I can tell you.

I'm curious; did she give into YOUR every whim and tantrum as a child?

Wishing you well in your journey.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Excellent replies back! I guess when you wanted to please your mother all of your life, for some reason, which I don’t know why, and then you have a psychotic brother who threatened my life since he was 18 - yes, you can say you can’t help me because yes, I am not well myself.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
lealonnie1 Jan 2023
Hopefully you'll really leave in 3 days and go back home, then sign up for some therapy to help you. You've gotten 200 comments here, but you're still asking "what to do/say" to your mother which indicates a need for professional guidance, imo. You can't break 60 year old habits and behaviors in a few weeks with a few comments on an internet forum! These issues between you and your mother go WAY back and you need someone working with you on a regular basis to help you break thru this toxic cycle going on so you'll allow yourself to be free. Maybe that won't happen until your parents pass, idk. But go find out. We're just repeating ourselves here on the forum at this point. Best of luck.
(3)
Report
See 3 more replies
Max;

We ALL want to please our moms and we all love our moms. I certainly did both of these things.

But the thing is, when your health is at stake (and yours is--you HAVE to go back and make sure that your cancer is still in remission, yet?) and when you find that you can't even start to think about retirement because your mom is throwing tantrums and demanding that you become her personal hands on caregiver when there are PLENTY of other folks who can do that--you have to start wondering if YOUR life EVER comes first, ya know?

Most parents bend over backwards to make sure that their kids' lives are better than their own. That they get the education, the emotional and medical support they need to start on the path to a productive life of giving back to their community and the next generation.

The work that a parent puts into a child gets paid forward, in my world view, not back to the parent (your mom might disagree with this).

I'm truly sorry that you're so "stuck" on making sure that your mom doesn't get upset at you. It must be an awful place to be.

Does your dad understand?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
Isthisrealyreal Jan 2023
The difference between people wanting to please their mom's boils down to some learn nothing will please them, put boundaries in place and others jump through flaming hoops until someone dies to please an unpleasable tyrant.

She has justified, excused and made her mthrs behavior acceptable for 63 years.

Pretty hard to admit this and many never do. Sadly!
(3)
Report
See 4 more replies
dear OP,

hug!! i wonder if your mother (like many abusive, screaming, dominator-ruler-wannabe, tyrant mothers), retaliates if you don't do what she ORDERS you to do?

if you fear her screaming, it's probably not just the screaming you fear. anyone can walk away from someone screaming. the trouble is, what are the consequences?

a lot of these abusive people have all sorts of strings they can pull on, and if you don't do as they want, they'll REALLY retaliate. i'm guessing your mother doesn't just scream, otherwise you would have done all that a long time ago: (1) walk out the room when she screams, (2) pay no attention to the screaming, (3) don't reward the screaming, etc., etc.

if it were so easy, you would have done it.
so the story is probably more complicated. maybe there are all sorts of consequences if you don't do as your mother commands.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
BurntCaregiver Jan 2023
@BOJ

If Max and her husband are paying the parents' mortgage then they have no way to retaliate. And if she walked away right now today APS would place two elderly and vulnerable adults (her parents) because they cannot function without a 24-hour caregiver slave. So really, there won't be any retaliation.
If they make threats that's what the police are for.
Max doesn't leave because she doesn't want to leave. For all of her complaining, venting, and lamenting she enjoys the drama and the martyrdom on enough of a level that it keeps her there.
She's exactly where she wants to be.
(3)
Report
See 2 more replies
BOJ, the OP and her husband pay the parents' mortgage. Because the parents gave all their retirement assets to the brother.

I guess it IS possible that Max's mom is like Tony Soprano's mom and has minions who are not "just" flying monkeys, but really dangerous folks.

BUT since all of the sacrifice of time, money and health has been by the OP, I am inclined to encourage her to learn to set some firm boundaries.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Max,

Did you look into doing online therapy?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Max,

I know that you don’t have children. I was adamant about raising my daughters to be independent. That is our job as a parent.

I don’t ever want my daughters to be my caregivers. It upset me terribly when I heard them say that they would care for me like I did for my mom.

I put a stop to that immediately and told them that I would never expect them to do anything other than being my daughters.

If you were a parent and you had a daughter, would you allow her to do everything that you have done for your mom and dad?

I seriously doubt that you would expect your child to do all of this, so why do you feel that your mom has the right to expect this from you?
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Think of your husband. What he has sacrificed all his married life. He must love you lots to put up with this other men would have left. Helping parents financially to get over a hump is one thing, but paying their mortgage monthly is another. They chose to support your mental brother, not you. They should be living on what they can afford. Just paying the mortgage for them should be enough and they should be very very grateful.

LET MOM SCREAM! She is a tyrant. You start pkging tonight. When your husband gets there he stays in the car. You tell ur parents time to go. Hug and kiss them. If Mom starts, say can't deal with this now DH is waiting and WALK OUT. Get a nice hotel up the road and have a nice dinner. ITS TIME TO GROW UP. You know this or you wouldn't have come on this forum and put up with us. Because...you know we r right. No one person should have this kind of control over another. You raise ur kids and let them fly the nest.

You know Moms going to scream whether u leave tomorrow or Saturday. Whats one day matter.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Regular posters, don't you feel like you're banging your heads against a brick wall trying to get through to max?

max, I have no suggestions that haven't already been said 200 times, different ways. I just hope you have the courage to some of them.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Daughterof1930 Jan 2023
Exactly, Polar Bear! I’ve decided to think of Max now sitting on a comfy chair with a view of the ocean, far from the tyrannical mother she’s finally broken free of, but still yanking the chains of everyone here just for funsies. It would beat the probably reality
(2)
Report
See 3 more replies
202 answers - way too much.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Max, years ago when I was in a less than desireable relationship, my therapist took a very direct approach with me. He gave me an assignment.

The assignment was to go to the movies.

I was very enmeshed and helpless. He gave me the name of the movie.

He told me which subway to get on.

He told me what time the movie was playing.

I think you should go out tonight. To a movie, to a mall, just OUT.

Don't ask permission. Just get out of your parents' house for a minimum of 2 hours, Like a grownup would.

Take a cab or car service if you have to, but GO OUT.

That is your first assignment.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
My therapist did this too. I went to Jazz Fest! I had a blast! Yeah, we all need breaks! Even if it is just going out for coffee.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Sorry for annoying you, but why are you even on a forum - maybe you must enjoy reading about other peoples’ miseries?


polarbear
2 hours ago
Regular posters, don't you feel like you're banging your heads against a brick wall trying to get through to max?

max, I have no suggestions that haven't already been said 200 times, different ways. I just hope you have the courage to some of them.


D

Daughterof1930
1 hour ago
Exactly, Polar Bear! I’ve decided to think of Max now sitting on a comfy chair with a view of the ocean, far from the tyrannical mother she’s finally broken free of, but still yanking the chains of everyone here just for funsies. It would beat the probably reality
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
Max,

You’re not the only one that has been criticized for having a long thread.

Honestly, who cares how long the thread is? Why should it annoy people if it’s long?

It doesn’t matter if your thread is a paragraph or a novel.

Anyone who doesn’t want to read it can and should skip it. Those who wish to support you will remain.

This is a support group for caregivers. You are a caregiver and deserve to speak about your concerns.

I hope that when you finally get to Europe, all of this will only be a distant memory.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
I taught for years at university and college. For those that don't know it, repetition is one of the bases for learning. Making your comments meaningful and relevant to the learner are others.

When we come here sharing our troubles and needing change in our lives we are exposed to new ways, new ideas, new thoughts. We need to learn about them. That happens best in an atmosphere of trust. IMO it's up to us as the longer time members of this forum to develop that and not to devalue any other member.

Max. I think you are learning some things that are useful to you. You are still here interacting and I believe that at least some of what you read is striking some chords inside you that you are and will benefit from.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
I agree, Golden

I must say that I am very proud of Max for standing up for herself and I too feel that she has as much value as everyone else, regardless of how she is responding to her circumstances.

There are respectful ways to communicate and disrespectful ways. I hope others will take your words seriously and realize the way they say things matter.
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
Some people are incapable of making changes.
There is one forum member who's been here for years. He's been complaining (for 8 to 10 years now probably) about his dad walking all over him and his wife and treating them like doormats, and how the stress is killing them both. He's been given advice again and again for many many years. Each time he comes back to complain, it's the same old things. He hasn't taken one advice or made one change to improve anything.

I told him I didn't believe he could make any changes, not even one. And I challenge him to prove me wrong. He hasn't.

Making changes is too hard, harder than enduring the abuse.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
maximus1 Jan 2023
To Polar Bear and the other posters who don’t believe I will change - Don’t worry about it. You just told it like it is. Believe me, I’m a New Yorker from Long Island and Brooklyn - I’m used to that!
(1)
Report
See 5 more replies
To everyone who just recently posted Golden, Need Help, Barb, Isthisreal, Bundleofjoy if I missed someone, please forgive me - thank you for your patience, understanding and support. You are the only people that I have ever divulged my inner emotions to besides my husband.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
You’re very welcome, Max. Anytime!

Believe me, I had an extremely long caregiver experience. I understand and know how hard it is. I also became ‘stuck’ for lack of a better word.

I am grateful to many who were patient with me.

You’ll get through this.
(1)
Report
See 4 more replies
Hi Golden, I’m going to change the subject a bit - just curious - I surmise that you are not American because of certain vocabulary you have used, for example - Mum, behaviour, and “at”university - did I guess right? You don’t have to answer if you don’t want to.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

That's correct, Max. I am not American. No problem answering. I am proud to be Canadian. 🍁
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Interesting observation, max. When I, a total stranger, provoked you, just slightly, you came swinging back. Evidently, you are capable of protecting yourself. But when an obnoxious, selfish, manipulate relative abuses you, you freeze up in total fear, incapable of thinking straight, not able to do anything except to sit there and be devoured.

Well max, you said you're from Brooklyn NY, meaning you are tough, street smart and take no BS from anyone.

Time to show it or else TALK IS CHEAP.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
maximus1 Jan 2023
Agreed polar bear❤️
(3)
Report
Max,

Are there any in person caregiver support groups near you? I enjoyed going to one that was led by a licensed social worker.

An ‘in person’ support group has a completely different vibe than an online forum.

The social worker was a caregiver to her own mother. She had been through quite a bit with her mom before she decided that placement was the best option for her mom.

Everyone had a chance to speak about their experiences. No one spoke out of turn. All were respectful and some of us even went out for coffee after the meeting.

Check to see if there are any ‘in person’ support groups nearby. I think you would appreciate the difference between an online forum and a face to face group.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Max, in case you haven't looked, Dorker's thread is YEARS long.

BUT as I said, she was able to "hear" what we were saying about
1. Boundaries
2. Saying "no".
3. Not caring so much about what her MIL, SIL and husband though about her behavior changes.

If you read her last post, her husband and SIL STILL talk about terribly sad it is that their mom ended up in "that place" (a good NH) because "no one" i.e. Dorker, was willing to sacrifice their sanity to make sure that entitled but impoverished MIL had EVERYTHING (including special dog treats, a particular dog groomer, homemade jello and saltless saltines) her heart desired.

Sonetime, ya gotta stand up to the insanity and say "basta".

Wishing you well.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Its 5:45 EST where I live. One more night to go, unless you took our suggestion to get a hotel. Have everything ready so you and DH can leave first thing tomorrow. Do not lag. Treat Mom like a child going to first day at Daycare. Hug, kiss on cheek and walk out the door. You know what happens when you leave a child at daycare. Yes they cry, yes they holler for Mom. A worker redirects them and next thing u know, they are playing with the other kids. Mom will be alright. Dad is there, give the man some credit.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

It's 7.20 on the Eastern Seaboard, the time zone that Max is in.

Max, I hope you are either in a hotel room or getting ready to leave your parents ' home (that you pay for) post dinner awaiting your husband's arrival.

AND that tomorrow you drive home.

If that's not happening yet, you have some 'splaining to do and we will help you fix it.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Max - you mentioned a while ago that you had had a very bad time with your brother who terrorized you. No one responded to that much. I know that has left you with some emotional scars. Your parents didn't deal well with him. Your family had and has very poor boundaries. This is what you learnt. I know what it is like to fear a family member. There were times, not that many, but there were some where because of mother's illness I feared for my life. You never forget that. I am sorry you have gone through so much trauma and stress. Counselling will help.

You are in my prayers to make good healthy decisions for you, which put you and your needs first.

Could you ever say to your mother - I need to go home and stay in my home for the foreseeable future. I need time with my husband - just the two of us. I need to see my doctor. I need to take care of myself...

Can you put your needs first?
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
Golden,

Oh yes, I can attest to this as well. I have horrible childhood memories of the crazy things that my oldest brother did.

Actually, it continued into my adulthood until I cut him out of my life.

I did take my mom to see him in the hospice facility before he died.

Unfortunately, he was a lost and troubled soul. I was relieved when he died because he was finally at peace.
(1)
Report
See 4 more replies
5 6 7 8 9
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter