Follow
Share
Read More
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
You guys are so right about a plan. We were just saying if we were killed on this highway (hope not) what plan do they have? I know they did have a discussion about a nursing home, but my husband said to me that's not a plan - which nursing home? They refused to acknowledge they were aging. For such intelligent and usually thoughtful planning people - what happened? It's not our responsibility. We have no kids and one of us will be alone and we are going to make a plan for us soon and it's our responsibility! If I was sick again, I would never live with my parents and burden them.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
It’s true, Max. Parents should not rely on their children to help them throughout their entire lives. It’s too much to expect from a child.
(0)
Report
Would it be possible for your father to go to rehab after hernia surgery ? I don’t know how long recovery for that is but my husband is getting that next week. Still doesn’t solve what to do with your mom if he could go. What about respite in AL for her while he recovers. Don’t let them in your house as them will never leave.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
Rehab is a great suggestion! My mom and dad always improved in rehab. Plus, the family can be at peace knowing that he is being cared for.
(2)
Report
Max, in what way do you find your parents to be planful? Or thoughtful?

Giving all their money to your abusive brother was a plan?

It sounds to me like like your parents have basically brainwashed you.

From what you've written, they sound thoughtless, selfish, manipulative and deeply abusive to you.

I'm just going by your description of their behavior.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Max,

I know that it seems like everything is up in the air right now but one thing is for certain. You aren’t the one to do the heavy lifting.

Your health is equally important to your parents. Even if you didn’t have health issues, your life is just as important as theirs.

It may appear as if there is no end in sight, which is extremely unnerving.

There is an end in sight. It does require that your parents accept that they must enter a facility. They don’t have money for private caregivers and you can’t accept that responsibility any longer.

Your husband is confused right now. He is loving and compassionate like you are. Please explain to him that a nursing home is the ONLY solution for this situation.

Maybe you see your parents as young at heart. In reality, your parents are old and will only require more care as time goes by. They are never going to be able to be independent again. You know this.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
MaximusRomeo Jan 2023
Oh no, my husband actually meant a nursing home.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
I doubt if your Dad will be able to get operated on in another State. Medicare no problem but supplements don't go from State to state unless Medigap. My DH was a UAW worker and ours may go state to state. My sister had cancer at 42 and wanted to have her chemo near home. She lived 2hrs away and 2 sm states away. Her insurance would not allow it so my Mom spent 8 months caring for sister at her house.

Max, this IS IT! This is when Mom and Dad have to finally see that they can't continue like this. I am going to be blunt. What would they have done if you had died. Your husband cannot be expected to take on that burden, its not his parents. You have had a serious scare. YOUR health is on the line. Why should ur husband loose you because of the selfishness of your parents. Its time that you parents are told they need to go into AL. Sell the house to pay for it. But you no longer can be at their beck and call. They need care that you no longer can give. If they loved you they would let you have a life. And do not pay their way. When the money runs out they can go into LTC together.

". I felt my chest exploding. I can't breathe!" Do you realize that chemo can effect the heart. What you are feeling is anxiety and not good. You also are worrying about something that may not happen. No need to worry because your answer should be NO and your husband should be there to back you up. NO Dad you cannot recuperate here. NO Dad you can't move in with us because...we will not be here all year long. NO Dad, caring for you and Mom stresses me out. Getting too old to deal with you and your problems, you have to figure it out on your own. (Senior caring for a Senior) If you finally go into AL we can help you with the move but you have to do the work.

If you get any calls from SWs, you tell them you cannot care for your parents the way they want. You don't live in the same State. You are a cancer survivor and the stress causes you anxiety, which u don't need. You have tried but they want it their way. No living with you is not an option. What they need is someone who can find them the resources they need because you can no longer be that resource. Again the answer is NO! You have finally throw you hands in the air and say "I am done!"

I am actually getting anxiety writing this. I am so happy my parents were not like this. There comes a time you have to stop banging your head against the wall. Its called tough love even with 90 yr old people. If you ever feel Mom and Dad need help, you call APS and allow them to take over. They have brought this on themselves by being to stubborn to see what they need to do. Burnt says: "Nothing will get an elder a one-way ticket to a nursing home faster than being stubborn".
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

By the way, my husband and I are both in favor of a nursing facility when needed. First of all, when we travel and retire to Europe we're thinking about renting our condo - just like they rented theirs. I
can imagine the screaming that's going to happen.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
Beatty Jan 2023
Move that focus. Away from any future fantasy reaction, any possible screaming. That's just your brain inventing some future drama for entertainment.

Focus on getting home.
Then on some sensible research & action.

Have you heard of the 6 thinking hats? I love them! Time to try on some new hats!! Less red hat. More white hat.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Breathe.
Simplify.
Drive the car home. To YOUR home (not theirs).

Telephones are wonderful things. Use them.

If parents ring with an emergency, tell them to hang up & call 911.

If/when they land in hospital, you will have time to arrange a call to their medical team. About their condition, about discharge plans, about their potential need of a Social Worker.

Drive home. Unpack. Put your feet into you OWN life again.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Max,

It’s great hearing you speak about going to Europe!

When you get there, let us know and I’ll open a bottle of wine to share a toast with you!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
MaximusRomeo Jan 2023
Can't wait to have wine tonight - want to join us? ❤️
(2)
Report
See 1 more reply
Love you guys and your replies. Read your posts to my husband and he agrees with everyone one of them. We are mentally and physically exhausted. We stopped off for a delicious spicy chicken sandwich to take home and we can't wait to retire to bed when WE want to and watch OUR movies. 💋to everyone!
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

Max, I'm very happy that you are detached from your parents day-to-day life. Your Mom only cared about you to the point of what you could do for them. You were no longer their daughter, you were their slave. Your Mom saying "I love you" is classic abuse after all you went through. To her credit, she was also probably caught up in the entitlement cycle. Hopefully, she will recognize this and take corrective action in the future.

Learn to manage from afar. You can do it. Everyone has emergencies. However, what is determined as an emergency is different amongst us. By learning to manage from afar, you will be able to save your strength and energy for the true emergencies.

Congrats to you and your husband to finally just walking out. Please take care of yourself.

P.S. Renting is a great way to help with the money outflow. It is even better if you can get a positive monthly cashflow without including the depreciation.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Max, you wrote: "You guys are so right about a plan. We were just saying if we were killed on this highway (hope not) what plan do they have? 

Max, YOU are so right! I am SO glad you see it clearly now.

Your parents' caretaking plan all along is you. You be the nurse, the maid, the cook, the azz wiper, the shopper, the driver, etc., live-in, 24/7/365.

Instead of "if we were killed on this highway...what plan do they have?", replace it with:

Mom, dad, I need to take care of my health problems. I can't be your caregiver, what's your plan? (Repeat again and again as necessary.)
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

So she screams.

So what?

(That is a quote from NeedsHelpWithMom's therapist)

Your parents need help. They need far more help than YOU can provide. But they need you a heck of a lot more than you need them.

Next time your mother abuses you verbally, screams or otherwise shows you disrespect, ask her what her plan is if you were to turn and walk away forever. "Because, mom, if you treat me like that, I'm walking away".

Do not say that unless you mean it. My DH used this on his mom (she had another child who accepted the abuse as his lot in life). My DH walked away and has never had a moment of regret.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
Barb,

Your last line is so helpful. Everyone who has ever struggled with their decision to walk away could learn a lesson from your DH.

“My DH walked away and never had a moment of regret.”

People need to know that it is okay on the other side of caregiving. They don’t have to be consumed with guilt. I think for those raised in FOG, we believed that the guilt will eat us alive if we walk away.

In reality, it is a huge relief to walk away and there is nothing to regret.

The time we spent in caregiving we can never get back. The things that we missed out on are gone. Those are my regrets.

Life is short and sometimes it is a huge balancing act. When it is out of balance, we suffer horribly.
(2)
Report
Last post - I promise! We called my parents to tell them we arrived home - how's your meatballs blah blah blah - at the end after saying goodnight - mom says- HOPE YOU ENJOY YOUR APARTMENT - that's because I told her I miss my home (after 2 months and 1 week). Sarcastic right? My husband said what she really wanted to say is you left me here being sick just because you miss your apartment?! She also sounded so glum. She was so nice yesterday saying I love you both etc.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
Max,

I am so glad that you’re home! How is Romeo doing? Now your fur baby has you all to himself! I bet he is loving it!

Most importantly, you and hubby are free to enjoy being alone together or spend time with friends.

It doesn’t matter what or how your mom expresses her opinion. She can be as passive aggressive as she wants to be. You know that you don’t need her approval to be in your own home.

Here’s to you enjoying your peace and quiet, Cheers! 🍾🥂.
(5)
Report
See 1 more reply
Max - I was going to suggest you share the posts with your husband. I am so glad you did and that you are back in your own home now. Well done!!! Care for your parents can be arranged from a distance. A number of us did that. Your life will get sucked down a very big black hole otherwise. Coming to stay with you while dad has surgery in NOT an option. be very clear on that.

Your mum blows hot and cold depending on whether she is getting her way - always has, always will. She will be charming sometimes and will scream at you other times. It is what it is.

I think you are still looking for her approval and her unconditional love. Everyone needs that but many of us do not get it from our parents. For whatever reason, your mum is not capable of that - nor your dad. Time to accept them as they are - very frail seniors who are getting more and more in need of help. Time also to accept, which I think you are, that you and your hub are not able to give them the care they need. Things started to be much more manageable for me once more professional people were involved in mother's care.

They may be suited to an assisted living facility or they may need more care. They may be able to manage where they are for a while with home aides several times a week. They need to be evaluated as to the level of care they need. Their local agency for aging will have information about local resources, Medicaid is available for people with limited financial resources such as your parents.

Barb's suggestion about contacting the social worker if either of them are in hospital is great. An SW can steer your parents in the right direction for their proper care. Both your parents are still mentally competent though I think your mother is slipping, so they can participate in making plans for their own care. If you want to oversee their care when they are not competent you need to have financial POA and be assigned as their medical proxy. These documents should be out in place asap. Perhaps you already have them and I have missed it in previous posts.

Put your own health and needs as a priority. Do what you have to do to keep stress levels down.

Keep your eye on your goals of retirement for you and hub in Spain, and a suitable facility for your parents in the US. We are always here to support you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
MaximusRomeo Jan 2023
Thanks for caring Golden ❤️💋
(3)
Report
Get a good night's sleep Max!
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
MaximusRomeo Jan 2023
💋
(1)
Report
I'm so glad you kept going and are now home!

I really thought you would turn around to tend to your mother.

Well done!
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Max, I have a personal trainer and this morning she was telling me her elder care woes with her in-laws. She was contrasting the way one of her BILs handles HIS parents with how her husband and his siblings deal with the same issues.

When BIL's parents started having fender benders, he went them and said "Mom, dad it's not safe for you to be driving any more. He took their keys.

When it was clear they shouldn't be living alone, she sat down with them and said "this isn't working. You need to move to AL". They picked one out and he helped them move.

Her DH'S family, by contrast, hints, makes vague statements about "not getting any younger", engages in long backs and forth about whether they should wait to go to a nice AL. The MIL has dx'ed dementia and her husband/caregiver is worn out. If he is hospitalized, they have a huge emergency on their hands.

BUT they are SO afraid of hurting mom and dad's feelings!

Max, be direct with your parents. I am a big believer in the idea that God/tge universe sometimes gives us a "trial run". This phone call from dad about his hernia? That was your wakeup call.

If mom can't be left alone without supervision if dad goes into the hospital overnight, then it's time to move them.

You need to have a direct, honest and short conversation about this with NO attention paid to your mom's histrionics.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
BlueEyedGirl94 Jan 2023
I think about this all the time with FIL. Since BIL and SIL moved in with him BEFORE he went downhill - we watched him decide he wanted to be dependent rather than need someone to take care of him first. He was independent when they moved in (their own need) and became dependent because they were there.

DH and I are all in favor of finding a Skilled Nursing Facility for him now- but they would need to move out of his home in order to prompt him leaving - as long as they are there he will not leave.

But if they don't proactively choose to leave, and something happens to them - there would be a mad scramble - because DH and I already know that we won't be moving in with him to provide care.

As it stands right now he is coming home from rehab tomorrow and we have a lot of concerns about the differences between what he and the staff are telling us he is capable of doing and what the staff and the doctor are telling us in the discharge paperwork. If the staff's verbal information is correct -he will be fine to come home. If the discharge paperwork is accurate - we may have some issues with him when we get home.

And if we have issues - we will be scrambling to find care if he isn't capable of helping himself in certain areas (specifically transfers and toileting) because neither BIL nor SIL can assist and we are an hour away. Not to mention he is 300lbs so realistically no one can really help.

DH and I talked about it today and outside of calling for an occasional lift assist if he only struggles periodically - if it is consistent and he is not able to do what they claim....we will have to hire 24/7 caregiverS (as in two at a time) to assist until we can find somewhere to move him - because if he can't transfer or toilet himself that is the line we drew a long time ago on what constituted able to stay in his home vs having to move him.

Because it isn't possible to find immediate placement and if he can't transfer he will literally need placement immediately. So the only option will be in home caregivers.

People often don't realize that they can go from having the situation completely under control to an emergent situation literally in the snap of their fingers and at least have to have a couple of emergency options to cover the gaps. Even our emergency options are for different scenarios these days.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
I know what you're saying, because they would either come up here for his operation or whatever because he actually has doctors in DC, or I would have to care for her down there, which I do not want to do either one. I already got the taste of what it's like being a caretaker - I never mentioned that my Dad about 7 years ago spent 7 months in the hospital up here in DC and I had to tend to my mother in my place. This is why Im frantic about caring for them. I was at Target shopping one day doing errands and she calls me up and told me to come home immediately because she had a pain in her chest. I had to leave my filled up cart to run home to her and she was ok when I arrived home. It was probably gas pains. Then she wanted to go out to dinner in which one of them was when I told her I felt sick (which ended up as C- DIFF) and she said don't worry you'll feel better when we go out. We drove to DC to the hospital everyday for 7 months. I had to do everything myself because my husband had to go on business trips and to the office. I wasn't able to take our papillon for his long walks that entire time. It was a nightmare and she was a little more mobile. Alot of people start caring when there parents reach a certain age - I have given myself to my parents all of my life and so has my husband. Of course, she loves us - we serenade her every Friday night with her favorite songs, we tease her and make her laugh, we pet her head and make sure she's ok, my husband massaged her legs, and we give her credit and say she's so giving and loving - so why at times us she bratty and so negative and hold grudges and says mean things?
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
BurntCaregiver Jan 2023
Max,

When I first took employment doing homecare for the elderly, I was sent out assignment with a senior caregiver to be trained. I was her last trainee because she was getting out of the hands-on business because she couldn't stand it anymore. She did it for 25 years. That seems to be the magic number.
Anyway, she taught me how to handle every situation that a fussy senior brat or a nasty, demented elder can throw at a person.
Don't tolerate any behavior from a senior that you would not tolerate from a child or anyone else. They do not get special treatment because they are old.
Would you tolerate verbal abuse, constant negativity, sabotaging, and gaslighting from say your spouse, a friend, or on a job?
Then don't tolerate it from the person receiving your care.
Would you tolerate temper tantrums, hitting, kicking, biting, and destruction from a child in your care?
Then don't tolerate it from the elder receiving your care.
This was a very valuable lesson my trainer/mentor taught me. It is why I have been able to do this work for as long as I did.
I also do not play games either. I live by the philosophy that England's Royal Family has lived by for centuries.

Don't complain and don't explain.

You should try it. No complaining about how poorly your mother treats you and no doubt she is nasty to you.
No explaining why you say no to something either. You do not give her your entire health history and plead your case for why you can't take her out to dinner.
You tell her plainly, 'I don't feel well. We aren't going out to dinner' then let that be the end of it.
You tell her plainly, 'I am leaving on this date. I'll set up homecare for you'. Then that is the end of it and you do it.
With all respect to you and your husband, don't you think there's something wrong and dysfunctional about your marriage if both of you have made your parents the center of your world? This is something both of you should explore in therapy.
Don't be a martyr, Max. It will ruin your life and the lives of the people who love you.
(7)
Report
Think about what I said - everyday going to the hospital and sitting there for 7 months straight 🥵😭(I never mentioned this)
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

You don't have to do that again. Arrange for their care in Florida. Say No to them coning up to you in DC. Other people can care for them this time and every time from now on.

Why does she get mean - because she is not so loving and giving and no matter how well you treat her she never will be. You can't make her into the mother you want by doing things for her and being nice to her. It doesn't work. You can't change her. You need to change you into caring for you more.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
lealonnie1 Jan 2023
These personality types always get mean when they don't get precisely what they want. Oh, they always shroud what they say in with grand gestures of "I love you so much" yet the actions say otherwise. When they don't get what they want, they turn ugly & the sharp claws & fangs come out. I had one of those mothers and my DH was always saying how she was incapable OF loving anyone (but herself); and I always fought that notion OFF b/c I was always 'told' how much she 'loved me'. But shown otherwise. The moral of the story is, Golden is right: your mother is not so loving and giving no matter WHAT, and it's up to YOU to acknowledge that Max. These are/were not the mothers every child longs for, no matter what lies we've told ourselves over the years. It's okay to relegate your parents' care to OTHERS now. You've done enough. You've been a good daughter, whether she recognizes it or not. YOU recognize it and say out loud so you're able to look into in-home caregivers and/or Assisted Living for them now. O/w, you'll feel FOG to the point of giving up your retirement years to care for them now until they pass.
(4)
Report
Max, I hate to break this to you, but your mother is NOT a nice person.

Is your husband only loving to you when you are doing exactly what he says to do? Or do you have adult relationship where all the adults are allowed to have opinions, desires and needs?

You mother doesn't respect you as an adult. She uses and manipulates you through Fear, Obligation and Guilt.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
lealonnie1 Jan 2023
Not only FOG techniques are used, but very shrewd manipulation and grooming techniques to keep the children convinced their mother is 'perfect' in every way, and to question such a thing is a betrayal. So we're conditioned from birth to 'know our mothers love us' & it's a very foreign concept to be told otherwise. Even when their behavior clearly shows us they're not loving or nice people, STILL we persist with that 'magical thinking' that they're The Perfect Mother b/c that's how we were trained and conditioned all these decades. Truly a thing that's FUBAR, I know. I feel what Max feels here........torn in half. Trying to believe mom loves her but still wondering why she's so mean to her at the same time.
(3)
Report
I’m wondering…

Barb, you said that your husband walked away from his mom, no regrets, right? I am assuming no guilt too.

Why do most men, (there are always exceptions) deal with this situation far better than women? Is it for practical reasons, work? Or temperament?

There are some women (like Lea, you and others) who NEVER considered taking on the ‘hands on’ responsibilities of caregiving but overall many of us feel that it was our responsibility. It’s so sad.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
BarbBrooklyn Jan 2023
NHWM, my brothers and I watched my mom care for a succession of dying relatives from the time we were very young. Then, my grandma (mom's mom) moved in with us when I was about 12.

My mother was an excellent caregiver, but had no support. She felt guilty, stressed and angry all the time. She thought this was supposed to an "honor". People told her how lucky she was.

I didn't have a mother who was emotionally available to me as a teenager.

I wasn't ever going to do that to my kids.

I stayed at home when my kids were young, but went back to work/grad school when they started school.

I got divorced and bought my own property with my own mortgage. There was no possible way I could have stopped working to take care of my mom in her home or ours.
(3)
Report
See 5 more replies
One time my mom said to me in a very calm voice (my mom never yelled), “I would have never spoken to my mother the way you just spoke to me.” I said, “That’s because grandma never treated you the way you treat me.”

My grandmother had a different temperament than my mom. Grandma was not rude but she was direct, extremely independent, fair minded and had a wonderful sense of humor! I absolutely adored her. She saw me get married but didn’t live long enough to see my children.

Mom didn’t always express her feelings. She suppressed them, then out of the blue, beware. Know what I mean? I am not sure how to explain. She wouldn’t always indicate that there was a problem.

Personally, I would rather someone tell me off, clear the air, then talk about it, rather than keep me in the dark about things.

Oh well…life is complicated at times and family dynamics can stink sometimes.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
maximus1 Jan 2023
My mom said she was very quiet when she was young. She said she became more outspoken as she aged (if I can believe that). She ran their restaurant, tile store, took care of her home, raised children and tried to give us a wonderful life. My mom was like your grandmother - tell it like it is, direct and doesn't take crap from anyone. Sometimes I thought she should be more diplomatic - it bothered me that her approach could be strong. She was very diplomatic in her businesses, but with family and friends, she was not. I can tell somebody off, but I also don't have to be so honest all of the time. I am also more realistic in my approach to life - my mom is not. She seems to listen to my advice and say I'm so bright etc., but on the other hand, I'm always wrong. So confusing?! She also can be the most giving, selfless person and then she can be so self-centered. How can she not realize this?
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
Max I want to point something out. You said your dad is going to have surgery but you would have to care of mom, not dad. Think about that.

Dad is 95 and he is still having to care for your mother.

Dad is having surgery but mom needs to be taken care of not dad.

Everything is about mom. You were sick but mom wanted to go out to dinner so you went.

Just because you did X,Y,Z in the past does not mean you have to continue doing X,Y,Z. You always have a choice.

Your dad probably got injured helping your mother when you left. Dad can only do so much and your mother is like an insatiable parasite that only cares about her survival and no one elses well being.

Dad can have his hernia surgery where he lives. They will need to hire someone to help mom if she is not capable of helping herself.

I dont understand about the money. Dont they get social security? What are they spending their monthly income on exactly? It is your right to know since you are subsidizing their living expenses.

Since you didnt have the talk with mom and dad while husband was there in person it will have to be done in the phone. A bit impersonal but better than the alternative of you going back to Florida.

Take care of yourself stress can feed cancer and cause heart attacks. You and your husband deserve a life together before one of you is too sick or dead to enjoy each other without the obligation of mom hanging over you.
Helpful Answer (7)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
Great point! No question that life rotates around the mom. Everyone else is second fiddle.

Sounds so much like my husband’s grandmother. She was one of the self centered people that I have ever known. My poor mother in law having to grow up with her!

My husband’s grandfather was a sweetheart. His grandmother was an amazing artist. Once she painted a portrait of her husband. She showed it to him. He was shocked!

He looked at her and said, “Please look into my eyes. What color are they?” She said, “Oh, I see that they are blue.” She painted his eyes brown! LOL 😆 They were married over fifty years and she didn’t even know his eye color!

She only paid attention to herself. He would catch the street car everyday to work at his office until his late 70’s because he said that she would have driven him crazy if he retired.
(2)
Report
See 3 more replies
Max I keep reading your posts and the more I read - the more she reminds me of my FIL. And I don't want her to remind me of my FIL because you seem to love her so much and I don't even want to name what I'm thinking. And maybe I'm completely off-base - because sometimes when you live up to your eyeballs in something for so long - you also start to see it where is actually isn't in other people. So take what I'm about to say with a huge grain of salt.

My FIL is a narcissist. He is an OVERT narcissist. The kind everyone thinks about when they think narcissist. Grandiose, can't handle criticism, huge attention seeker, completely self-involved, his needs must be met above everyone else's, does not really live in our reality - he creates his own and fabricates narratives to match his reality, craves admiration. You name a narcissistic trait - he's got it. He spent my DH and his sister's entire childhood being abusive and pitting them against each other - where each of them thought the other was the Golden Child (favored child) and they were the Scapegoat. He did this with intention. My MIL spent years crafting how she dealt with him simply as a survival instinct. And now as caregivers we are having to learn our way around dealing with an aging narcissist.

But there is another kind - and they are harder to recognize. The COVERT narcissist. They don't seem like they are narcissistic at first glance. They seem the reverse. They are often passive aggressive and self-deprecating. As mothers - they tend to play the victim and shift blame to their children and set incredibly high expectations for their children.

And the most at risk in the path of a COVERT narc mother is the GOOD DAUGHTER. You want to be good, you want to make her happy. You will always feel guilty and you aren't even sure why you feel guilty! And they have a way of making you feel bad about yourself. Her needs are the most important, but when you have needs, you are overreacting or too sensitive. She is the eternal victim. And the most key thing I've read about is the fact that she may parentify her daughter in the quest to get her needs met - literally appropriate her daughter from her own life in order to make sure she gets what she needs. And that culture of guilt thing I mentioned - NO ONE is better at that than the covert narc mother. She needs YOU to feel bad if you don't do what she wants, even if YOU are right.

Covert narcs - like Overt narcs, will play siblings against each other.

And the hardest part is that as children - it becomes so normalized that you don't even realize it is happening and by the time you are an adult and can recognize that there is something inherently wrong with the relationship dynamic, the damage is already done. You have to work very hard to change your own mindset to break the cycle.

Cast of characters often include a passive father who enables her behavior and a golden child brother (or sister). And virtually no one will recognize that her behavior is anything other than a loving mother who invested so much into her child and now is reaping the benefits of a loving daughter. This is NOT new behavior. You have been dealing with this your entire life.

So...if you haven't entirely skipped my post because you think I'm crazy - consider the possibility. As I said, I certainly can't make any assumptions about your mother. I don't know her. I just know that so much of what you are describing sounds just like my FIL and the issues we constantly deal with on a daily basis. You don't come to the realization overnight. It comes in stages and once you recognize it, you don't even know what to do about it.

But its something to consider. If it is even potentially possible it might give you some tools to help you deal with her going forward. Because if it is on the table, it changes your entire approach. Because you have to shore up your spine and really dig in and take all of the advice here and put on your armor!

Hugs!
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
lealonnie1 Jan 2023
https://lifelessons.co/personal-development/covertpassiveaggressivenarcissist/

Best article EVER: 25 Signs of a Covert Passive-Aggressive Narcissist. I was gob smacked when I recognized so many of these 25 examples in my own mother. Mind bending.
(3)
Report
See 4 more replies
Max, I'm sorry Dad has a hernia.

How is HIS planning ability to deal with it?

To seek advice, to arrange whatever may be needed eg extra services to help him at home after surgery, or if he thinks that won't be suitable, a his & hers rehab/respite arrangement.

It's the same again. It will keep happening. Again & again & again.

You must take over & lead. Follow their orders & do whatever they want. Or stay away & out.

Whatever option you choose is fine. No judgement! But ensure you communicate it.

It's not kind or honest to your parents to let them assume you will do this or that, fly back, put them up etc be their whole plan if you won't be.

Decide your action.
Then tell them.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

What are your parents doing with their social security income? Are they still giving money to brother? Have you asked to see their income and spending or do you just give them money to pay mortgage every month? What happens if they leave this house or condo to brother when they die? Hopefully it is in your name and you have it as a protected asset for yourself.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report
maximus1 Jan 2023
No they are not giving money to my brother because he left a psychiatric ward and he doesn't want to be found. He would have been reminding me to have my Dad send him his monthly money if he was still receiving money. The condo will be ours. My Dad pays for assessments and other condo fees, we pay the mortgage only. The condos or apartments in our area are far more expensive than what we are paying now for them, so we cannot pay for them here. My Dad had plenty of money to live out their lives with. We were all deathly afraid of my brother, who by the way was taking pre-med courses at Duke University and then left and then went to get an accounting degree which he got straight A's and didn't finish that and then joined the Marines and got an honorable discharge, and then never became anything. He became an abusive alcoholic. Mom never wanted to admit that he was not mentally stable. For an Italian family, who is supposed to have close ties to one another, both sides of my family were dysfunctional. My Dad left home at 14 years old to live with his grandmother because his mother was crazy. My mom's parents separated because my grandfather was a womanizer. My close aunt got a divorce when her son was young. My aunt terrorized my grandmother. My husband and I know the real reason my parents are clingy and are desperate for family, they lost their son, and no one in their family ever acknowledged their accomplishments because both sides were jealous, ignorant people. So they are always fishing for compliments and saying you learned everything from us. With all of their accomplishments in life, we now learned that they are very insecure. They actually always entertained people and they still have friends, so why do they need to be around us so much? They literally don't have family.
(0)
Report
Max, we need you to remember 3 things:

1. You don't HAVE to do anything for your parents.

They can tell you that you HAVE to do stuff till the cows come home and it doesn't make it true.
You ARE allowed to say "no" to your parents.

2. You are allowed to hang up if your mother starts screaming at you, or tries to guilt you.

3. Your parents are adults who are responsible ONLY for themselves. THEIR funds should be paying for their housing and care. Not yours.

That's how "normal" families operate.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
golden23 Jan 2023
Amen!!!
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Max - It is very confusing when you are given such different feedback at different times. When we are very young we form our self image from feedback from others. As we grow and mature we shape our own self image and self esteem in response to our inner and outer worlds,

I realized when I was quite young that my sister and mother didn't see me as I saw myself. I felt in many ways they didn't know me. For sure I struggled with low self esteem at times which was due to feedback from my mother and sister but the more I distanced myself from them, the healthier and stronger I got. But at least they were pretty consistent

The yoyo feedback you get is like torture which breaks you down and is designed to keep you where your mother can control you. For your mental and physical health you need to get away from it.

Why does she do it? I believe that your mum has a disorder of some kind. Normal people do not behave as she does. Theories range from nurture (parenting and environment when young), to nature -genetics and/or neurobiology. Or, I suppose, some combination of these.

In our family it appears to me to clearly be genetics as this personality crops up in my mother's family - usually women, very bright academically, and very hard to get along with. They can have siblings who are entirely normal. My aunts and uncles were lovely people, Mother apparently, was difficult from birth. My sister has a version of it and my daughter and granddaughter. I have been assessed as normal, in that regard anyway! 😉

So, yes, it is confusing. I wondered "why" they did this or that for a while as I was growing up, but finally decided it didn't matter why. So much was wrong, it was bad for me, and I needed to look after myself.

I hope you are getting there. (((((((hugs))))))
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jan 2023
I spent a lot of my childhood confused too. We don’t sort it out until we are adults and away from home.
(3)
Report
No they are not giving money to my brother because he left a psychiatric ward and he doesn't want to be found. He would have been reminding me to have my Dad send him his monthly money if he was still receiving money. The condo will be ours. My Dad pays for assessments and other condo fees, we pay the mortgage only. The condos or apartments in our area are far more expensive than what we are paying now for them, so we cannot pay for them here. My Dad had plenty of money to live out their lives with. We were all deathly afraid of my brother, who by the way was taking pre-med courses at Duke University and then left and then went to get an accounting degree which he got straight A's and didn't finish that and then joined the Marines and got an honorable discharge, and then never became anything. He became an abusive alcoholic. Mom never wanted to admit that he was not mentally stable. For an Italian family, who is supposed to have close ties to one another, both sides of my family were dysfunctional. My Dad left home at 14 years old to live with his grandmother because his mother was crazy. My mom's parents separated because my grandfather was a womanizer. My close aunt got a divorce when her son was young. My aunt terrorized my grandmother. My husband and I know the real reason my parents are clingy and are desperate for family, they lost their son, and no one in their family ever acknowledged their accomplishments because both sides were jealous, ignorant people. So they are always fishing for compliments and saying you learned everything from us. With all of their accomplishments in life, we now learned that they are very insecure. They actually always entertained people and they still have friends, so why do they need to be around us so much? They literally don't have family.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
golden23 Jan 2023
Max - thanks for sharing so much. It helps us to have context. I'm going to address a couple of things tonight.

" My husband and I know the real reason my parents are clingy and are desperate for family, they lost their son and..."

I lost my youngest son. When I say lost, I mean he died from an assault when he was 23. I know a number of mums who have lost adult children. None of us became clingy to our remaining children. or desperate for family.

My family was very dysfunctional - alcoholic father, Borderline Personality Disorder narcissistic mother and narcissistic some kind of disorder sister. That did not make me cling to my children. They live their own independent lives. We enjoy one another's company when we get together by mutual choice. We have rubbed some rough corners off of one another, certainly, and we have all grown in the process.

I agree they are insecure, even jealous, which is a characteristic of narcissistic people. I don't believe anything you can do will make them feel secure. It hasn't happen yet after all the time and effort you have given them. Security comes from within

They need you around to prop them up, to be their servant child. It's about control.
(5)
Report
This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter