Follow
Share

Hi,



My mom has had a caregiver for 13 years since she had a surgery. She came most days for about 3-4 hours a days for years and then moved farther away and was able to come only three days a week. My mom made do with me ordering Door Dash meals on off days. She needs more help and so I hired a geriatric care manager who brought in a new caregiver two more days a week. They charge $39/hour. She has been paying the previous helper $30/hour.



The old caregiver said that she was going to write herself the checks for $40/hour from now on since that's what that other 'fat incompetent girl' is being paid. I don't know how she found out but it's not important. She already was paying herself for hours she doesn't work and had charged items on my mom's Costco card in the past as well.



My mom has been completely dependent on her since I live far away. She really likes how take-charge and outgoing she is and doesn't like other caregivers much usually. Finding new caregivers and training them is more than I can really deal with. We are at this person's mercy. My mom has refused to move closer to me or into assisted living. I told her she has a year and will have to leave her house when she turns 90 (she just turned 89), but this new development with her old caregiver may speed things up. She will now be paying $4000/month for 22 hours/week of care while living on a reverse mortgate. It's not sustainable.



Is this elder abuse? And if so, does it really change anything? We still need this person and I don't have the ability to fire her right away without upending my life. What do people do in these situations?

Find Care & Housing
As to the caregivers on board currently, neither one is worth keeping. Hire replacement caregiver(s) through a respected agency asap. Agencies often deal with situations like yours where the family is located remotely.

Also reevaluate whether your current geriatric care manager is actually helping you or making things harder for you. It sounds like quite possibly you could get better results by also firing the geriatric care manager (has the geriatric care manager been beneficial to you in any way?) and deal directly with a reputable caregiver agency for new in-home caregivers.... and.... probably consider getting a consultation with an elder law attorney regarding the caregiver who has been stealing and how to handle the home sale/reverse mortgage situation.

Sounds like there's a real goat rodeo going on at your mother's house with too many highly paid "professionals" who are not only unhelpful but actually making things worse.

Should be fairly simple to address:
1- find a reputable caregiver agency in your mother's city. Contact them by phone and explain your situation. Get the ball rolling with them.
2- Fire the old caregivers when the replacement caregivers are available to start the job.
3- Fire the geriatric care manager if you think this is an expense that has little value.
4- Elder Law Attorney consultation.
5- Celebrate - yay, you did it! Good job.
Helpful Answer (7)
Reply to LostinPlace
Report
Grandma1954 Jun 16, 2024
Amen to what you have said.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
You've handled all of this remarkably well.

It may not be elder abuse on the part of first caregiver, but it certainly is insubordination and should not be tolerated. If you have actual concrete proof of stealing, then a police complaint might be in order, but be careful about slinging such accusations.

Why don't you fire first caregiver and add hours with second caregiver? I know, I know, your mom has refused, refused, and she doesn't like most caregivers so she's going to refuse some more. Here's a secret: Mom doesn't get to run the show! That's right! She qualifies as a Senior Brat. She needs to be reined in and given the straight skinny. 1) You are in charge. 2) If she insists on not liking the caregivers you hire, she can go to assisted living, where she'd be better off with activities, friends, attention, meals and a solid routine. Get her into a nice place, stop the reverse mortgage nonsense, sell her home to pay for her care, and you can stop dealing with the three-ring circus at mom's.

Mom really belongs in a facility, so start looking. No matter what mom says she will or won't do.

"But my mom won't---" She'll have to if you give her no other choice.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to Fawnby
Report
shirenagel Jun 16, 2024
Thank you, Fawnby, this is where it is headed for sure. I don't think the new caregiver is working out either so it's either make one last-ditch attempt to find a competent caregiver to do all the hours or move her to AL. That will be a huge task but it seems like the time has come.

I only just got POA two months ago so this is all hitting like a ton of bricks.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
Thank you so much to those who answered my questions appropriately and with kindness. No thanks to those who felt the need to attack me for a situation that I did not create. I am trying to untangle a mess here while trying to deal with my own kids, career, perimenopause, financial issues, and more. Some people are really careless with others' feelings. Read the replies before you answer a question that wasn't asked without knowing the situation. Shame on you for shaming me.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to shirenagel
Report
Geaton777 Jun 18, 2024
Just make sure you do what makes your PoA active, according to the document. If you don't, then the old caregiver will still have influence with your vulnerable and trusting Mom. Getting the financial control away from that woman is the correct first step (after activating your PoA). If your Mom has a credit card, I'd be reviewing the purchase history: anything that looks suspicious should mean you report it to the company so that they issue your Mom a new, different number. You may want to talk to a banker at your Mom's bank about any acitivity with her account, past and present. You will need to take your PoA paperwork there and go through their onboarding process. You may want to freeze your Mom's credit for good measure (she doesn't need a credit rating at her age).
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
You pay what they ask or you don't use them.
It's pretty much that simple.
You can explain that the care in home will not be sustainable at these rates for very long, and then you can move your mom when they are NOT sustainable. Her being out of the home will result in the reverse mortgage loan coming due. Home will be sold. The proceeds will sustain mom in care so long as she can afford it. Mom will go on Medicaid when she is out of funds.

It seems pretty clear cut to me. The new caregiver IS getting quite an exorbitant rate, and that is where I personally would begin cutting costs. I would find another caregiver who would work at the rate you are paying. In fact ask your long term caregiver to assist you in finding one and tell her you are no more pleased with this high rate than she is. Ask her to find a friend she can work with well and at her rates and it's settled.

Eventually these in home care things atttempted from out of town, to be honest, become impossible.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
shirenagel Jun 16, 2024
The agencies all charge $40/hour. The other caregiver is private and under the table so we get no insurance, bonding, etc. for her but she doesn't pay taxes. The new caregiver is through an agency and probably only makes half of what we pay. This was a stopgap measure as an act of desperation but I will have to put an ad on craigslist and hire someone privately to pay less. This is much more risky and labor intensive for me but I could get lucky and find a wonderful retired person who just wants a part-time gig.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Sigh. This is why managing an elder to 'age in place' is so hard.

If the elder finds it hard to self-run their help, family can step in. But the needs & management needs grows.. Mission Creep (you have been living it!)

Good on you for getting a Geri Manager. (Many set themself on fire instead). But do check this is actually an improvement.

If home care is no longer working well, due to whatever (lack of staff, less than optimal staff, high costs, Mom's refusal to allow new staff), well.. Seems your Mother has some decisions to make about how she lives.

Is it time to consider assisted living? Be more social.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Beatty
Report
Beatty Jun 16, 2024
PS I just read all the replies. What about a Care Agency, for this last try? Give it 3 months. For both Mom & you.

Get yourself well again & properly over that awful Covid. Added stress could add to any post virus brain-fog.
(1)
Report
See 2 more replies
Shoot--when I worked Elder Care I made $9 an hour. And that was 15 years ago, so not that long!

$40 an hour?? I'm sorry, but that's highway robbery. And you admit this woman writes her own paychecks? And uses mom's Costco card and, what else? Oh, she sounds delightful in the mix (heavy on the sarcasm there).

This is why you really need to go through an agency. When there are issues, the agency handles them. Bookkeeping is a big deal. The CG's log hours and what they did during their shift. I'm afraid you're being taken advantage of, big time.

If it's simply not possible to stand up to your mom, tell her exactly how many months she has with private CG's before she will not have the choice of choosing her CG's. She'll be in a NH, and maybe not a nice one. I'm not trying to say that you should scare her, but since she's private paying for all this--she should know the gravy train is going to be empty pretty soon.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Midkid58
Report
shirenagel Jun 16, 2024
Unfortunately in the Los Angeles area $40/hour is the going rate at a minimum. The reason her assistant writes her own checks is my mom has macular degeneration and her vision has become really bad over the last year or two. She has done everything for my mom for many years but recently she has become increasingly difficult. I think she may be going through her own dementia issues. I obviously need to fire her but the alternatives are really hard to implement. I know I'm looking at a long involved process and it feels overwhelming.
(4)
Report
Seems none of this is working and the wrong person, mom, is driving the bus. Time for a complete change of tactics and plan. Mom moves to where help is available that meets her needs, house is sold to pay for it, two incompetent caregivers are let go, along with a care manager, and hopefully life becomes easier to manage. Just the fact that a hired caregiver has access to mom’s money and knowledge of mom’s business would be enough for me to bail on the current mess
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Daughterof1930
Report
shirenagel Jun 17, 2024
Yes, when I got POA two months ago I started changing the whole fiscal situation. I told the old caregiver that I would be moving all of the financial duties out of the house and handling them myself and requiring all cash be tracked and I think that is what has set her off.
(5)
Report
See 2 more replies
Response to your reply to me. I am a sofie too but I learned to take over. Mom does not run the show anymore and get your help. You need to be firm and stick by your guns. Get comfortable with the word No.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report
shirenagel Jun 17, 2024
Yep, it's happening, I'm being pushed too far. This is just out of hand. I'm an anxious wreck from it all. I may drive down there Wednesday since I have a day off and just move her into a home.
(2)
Report
Fire her. She got sassy pretty fast and for no real reason, bu I suspect your Mom was her gravy train. Tell your Mom a therapeutic fib, since she'll never believe this woman was playing her. Make sure to block her number and change the locks, keypad codes and anything else you or the GM can think of. To find the very wonderful caregiver I hired for my Aunts (for 6 years) I had to go through several losers first. That's just how it goes.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Geaton777
Report
shirenagel Jun 17, 2024
I don't think she liked when I told her I was taking over the finances. The more I step in there the more angry she gets. Bad sign.
(4)
Report
See 5 more replies
I'm trying to hire two caregivers for my mom and decided instantly to pay both the same since I assume they may talk.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to firsttimer1
Report
shirenagel Jun 16, 2024
Yes, this makes sense if they are both private. Since one is through an agency and licensed, bonded, insured it means that she probably only makes $20/hour. My mom's situation is messy. Good thing you are starting from scratch. Good luck finding good people.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter