My Mom seems to have great memory but experiences imaginary people, places and things. Is this normal for people with dementia?
Mom is 89 years old and has been blind for about 10 years. Just a few years ago, she would describe something that she thought she could see and when I told her what was actually there, she would say, "oh, my eyes must be playing tricks on me." But now she insists that what she is experiencing or seeing is real and gets angry if I say otherwise. The psychologist at her rest home told me to just go along with her imaginations, which include talking to people/children that are not present and wanting me to join the conversation. Mom's family and friends have all learned to agree with Mom no matter how strange her imaginations are. Many of the imaginary things she sees seem to be the same and there every day. What puzzles me is that, other than these imaginations, she seems so rational, logical and bright with an excellent long term memory and a pretty good short term memory. My family and I had become aware of this last August, but she has weirder and weirder experiences all the time and they seem to happen more often as time goes by, with no affect on memory. Three of her doctors say this is early onset of dementia. Is this normal? I thought dementia patience lose memory, rationalization and logic. How can she be so logical and communicate clearly, precisely and logically yet still have these weird imaginations?
But about 40% of those who have dementia have some kind other than Alzheimer's. Not all of the other kinds have memory loss as the primary symptom.
In Lewy Body Dementia, for example, memory loss is less pronounced than it is is ALZ. As virtualhorizon says, hallucinations are often the first noticeable symptom. Delusions are common. Executive function, including decision-making, suffers. You might want to check out the LBD association's web site to see if any other symptoms seem to apply to your mother. NOT that I'm trying to diagnose your mother! But so many of us have limited exposure to the wide range of dementia symptoms possible and a little more knowledge might be useful.
It really does not sound to me like this is the normal aging process you are seeing. It sounds like the beginning of dementia. It may help you to accept that, at least tentatively, and see what develops. This gives you an explanation of Mom's behavior, and a framework in which to respond to her.
The advice to go along with her imaginings is quite common from professionals. It does help in many cases. In my support group was a woman caring for her husband, a minister, with LBD. He frequently saw children in their home, and he wanted to care for them. He'd ask her to set places for them at the table at mealtime. She'd tell him that "The kids just ate while watching a video" or "Their parents will be coming for them in a half an hour and asked that I not feed them." She went along with his delusions but stopped short of feeding the kids! She never tried to convince him that there were no children there. That was his reality and there would have been no way to reason him out of it. In the beginning I tried reasoning my husband out of delusions, but I learned that life was better for him and for me if I could go along with him and redirect him. If you have not joined the rest of the family in accepting your mom's delusions, I recommend trying it.
If at all possible, this would be a very good time to refrain from arguments with your mother. If she does have early stage dementia she is losing her ability to reason, and arguing with her is kind of not fair -- all the brain power is on your side. Obviously you do not need to abide by the decisions she makes, but try to relate to her without a lot of argument and negative emotion. She cannot help her impairments, and you cannot change them.
One of the best moves I made was to join a support group of caregivers whose loved ones had the same disease my husband had. It can be scary -- you'll hear dreadful stories about more advanced symptoms -- but it is also immensely affirming to hear that others are coping with challenges similar to yours.
Do stay in touch here. We are also a support group!
I would say that the three Drs. may be right.