Follow
Share

Dear Aging Care,


I am in my late 40s, live alone with my dog and lead a happy and successful life. I grew up in a home that was emotionally unstable. Weak mother, dominant and emotionally abusive father, borderline physically abusive at times, but never crossed the line. Childhood dominated by listening to parents scream, fight endlessly. Awful. In my teen years, my father was horrible to be around, I did everything I could to avoid being at home. I felt like I had a crazy father, and I begged and pleaded for my mother to divorce him and get away from that sheer toxicity. At the time, I didn't realize just how messed up the family was because it was the only thing I knew growing up. However, I was a child with low self-esteem, overweight, poor grades, and very little confidence. I had started to "bloom" in my early 20s and realize my emotional and professional potential, and when I moved away to graduate school, I BLOOMED. Having my own "space" made my self-esteem skyrocket, confidence, and all the rest of it, and I realized then how toxic being around my family was growing up and how what I took to be "normal" at home was totally dysfunctional. I realized my father was basically a narcissist, he has never once apologized for anything to me in my life. If I had a child, I would not want my child to be around him. He's weak, emotionally abusive, does not take responsibility for his actions, and it's always someone else's fault. I stopped talking with him 20 years ago, though I've maintained mostly a phone/text relationship with my mother. I sent my father a note about 2 years ago thanking him for raising me as a way of closure and to let him know even though we don't speak, I still honor him as my father. His response, that I learned through my mother, was basically "FU, and if he appreciates me so much why doesn't he visit . . . and if he doesn't visit me soon, I'm cutting him out of the will." That's how he is, there is no reciprocation for a kind act, there is no "My son just sent me a nice letter, I'm glad he's doing well, I'm going to reach out and build a relationship with him" or anything like that. The more you give, the more he'll take and want to control. I could not believe his reaction to my letter. It just confirmed why I don't talk to him (I refuse to subject myself to emotional abuse by ANYONE), and I've maintained a phone/text relationship with my mother mostly for HER, because it's important to her. Do I "like" my mother? No. Overall, a friendly relationship. I send her an Xmas gift every year. She hasn't sent me one for 20 years, probably to punish me for not coming home for Xmas and tolerating abuse.



She had a stroke three days ago (age 77). 1000 miles away from where I live. My Dad is caring for her and she has lots of family with her as well (sisters, relatives, etc.). If I go see her at the hospital I will be emotionally abused by my father, guaranteed. He already hates me, and will take out his pain of seeing my mother in the hospital out on me. He will attack me for not visiting for the longest time, etc., he won't be "Thank you for coming, it's great to see you, we should make amends." That's not how his brain works. He will just use the situation to emotionally abuse and launch guilt trips on me.



I do not subject myself to being abused, and if I am, I either confront the abuser directly or leave the environment. That's my own healthy response to abuse and makes me who I am. If I go see my mother, I will either 1) confront my father when he launches into emotional abuse, which will end very badly and ugly for all involved, or 2) leave and come back home. I know my mother would benefit from seeing me, even for a little while, to hold my hand. She chose to keep him in her life though, not me. I am monitoring the situation from afar and will speak with my mother on the phone when she is able, to provide support.



Am I doing the right thing? Or should I go and take his abuse for my mother's sake?



D.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Your father is a Narcissist and Mom enables that because, she has been beaten down. She may even have had a parent with Narcissist tendencies and sees no problem with how Dad acts. Your brother, it may be learned behaviour he may too have inherited Narcissist tendencies. Its a personality disorder. Brain is wired differently. These people will never admit they are or did wrong. They can't do therapy because they can't see where they are wrong, i

I have a friend, sweetest and the most giving person. But her one daughter and her mother are Narcissists and gang up on her. She can't do anything right. She has been cut off from her granddaughter. She now lives in another State with her other daughter, doing so good. She just glows now. She has excepted how things are and has chosen to stay away.

Thats what happens with Children of a Narcissist parent. They too are Narcisstic, or looking for love thats not there or like u, they walk away. Which is the better of the 3, walking away.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
kbuswave Jun 2023
Thank you JoAnn for your reply. I think how you characterize my Mom is accurate, she used to try to get away from him, but then I think just gave up and decided to play another narrative of events in her mind to normalize their relationship. Just a bad marriage, really. I agree with what you say about the narcissism as well, and have been very careful in my own life to not repeat patterns. I'm also careful to take full responsibility for my life, but that's also because I decided to distance from that dynamic because I knew it was very unhealthy. I don't hate my dad, in fact I recognize a lot of his positive qualities in me (he's charismatic, works hard, etc), that was the point of my note to him, kind of letting him know on a higher level that I honor him, even if we're not meant to keep in touch. Would I befriend him if I met him in a crowd? Not in a million years.

Up to the point that I broke away, the family dynamic had been under his rule, he decided the energy every day. Negative one day. Positive the next. Depending on his mood. You know that feeling of anxiety you get when you're around someone like that. Being away from that is the heathiest decision I've ever made. You might be right as well, there is no changing that kind of thing. I think my mother realized that, thus the mantra "That's just the way dad is." So, you either choose you can be around it and accept it, or you choose to not be around it and focus on your own energy/life. I'm at peace with it. Only my mom's stroke has made me re-evaluate how much I can still keep a distance from him moving forward. Before the stroke, I had no regrets on my relationship with him (which was none, boundary, nice). Now that the stroke has arrived, well, the title of this post that I'm conflicted about.
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
UPDATE: I just wanted to update you all on a couple things. First, my Mom is improving a bit after surgery and is moving both arms and is understanding who is speaking with her, so that's great. I'm keeping tabs through my brother on how she's doing. Will continue to do so, and will likely send her a video of me speaking with her and playing piano for her that someone can play to her on their IPAD.

The second update is not about my Mom. It's about me, and the process I'm going through since her stroke occurred. Just in case this update is helpful or useful to anyone as you may be relating your own experience with regards to your parental families, and the process of healing, etc. Before her stroke, I was totally fine with how I was relating to my parents. I kept in touch with my Mom, didn't speak with my Dad (for good reasons), and had a very healthy boundary that way. No doubts about how I was living my life. I ceased contact with my Dad years ago because I made it a policy to not relate to people who are unaccountable for their actions or mistreat others, who never apologize, who treat you poorly and then expect YOU to apologize to them, who can't love unconditionally, and project insecurities on you. About 20 years ago, I had enough of that, and when my Dad "scolded/interrogated me" (a mid-20 year old, paying his own bills, etc.) like I was a 5-year old KID, and blamed me for my mother's tears because I arrived at Xmas 3 days "too late" apparently, I had enough. I confronted him 1st time EVER, and he suggested I leave his house. I did. I knew then what I am reminded of now. The way he treated me (and has done so for years, to my Mom, brother as well) was 100% wrong, and it was NOT my fault. I have the right to make my own choices. At the time, I remember thinking, "If he contacts me and apologizes for the way he treated me and shows ANY accountability/remorse for his actions at Xmas, we might have a shot at some kind of relationship." That day predictably never came, just like no other day came before it where he ever apologized for his mistreatment of me, my mother, or brother. I felt so strong leaving that toxic relationship behind, and through time also realized, as one of you so aptly noted, my mother was an accomplice to all of that crap growing up. She never stood up for the kids while my father acted out his emotionally regressed self on all of us. That's why my relationship with my Mom has always been a bit lukewarm, civil, friendly, but never truly bonding. So, my confidence in how I relate to the family was totally fine BEFORE the stroke.

Enter stroke. Total dive, back to being a kid again. Worried about what Dad will think of you if you don't visit. Worried about what brother will think if you don't visit. "You're making Mom cry, don't you love your mother you selfish prick?" All those doubts came back. I was about to head over to see her and potentially go back on all that I had established for myself. My dog kept me from doing so, because given his status, he can't cross the border (details don't matter here, just to say he saved me from a bad decision yet again!)

Long story short, as many of you probably already know, when the "bomb" drops, it's just a test. Process it. Work through it. Suspend action. You'll be back in a few days and will not have been manipulated by emotional circumstance. You'll remember why you left and why you aren't going back. Your life. The "adult" in you comes back fast, you "rebound" from re-experiencing the child in you and feeling weak and insecure about your choices. Yesterday, I was still fighting with the "bad son" in my dad's voice, for doing nothing more than avoiding a man not accountable for his own behavior or actions. I forgive him, but choose to avoid him. I am healthy. My OWN voice again.

Thank you to all for your support. I'll update on my Mom again soon. Be well. I needed this group these past couple days, you were there for me. Thank you. KB.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
bundleofjoy Jun 2023
has your brother taken care of them all this time? is he the one who was left holding the bag, and having to deal with the abuse? is he the reason your parents are doing relatively well (in the sense that they would be even worse off, without his help)? if any of this is true, please say "thanks a lot" to your brother. he deserves your gratitude.
(2)
Report
See 2 more replies
Just to add as well, part of me feels like just going, and if he acts up, putting him in his place as an adult to a child. But I don't know if that only "works" in my head/imagination, and won't in reality. I can handle him, but only if I can confront or correct him as an adult would correct a child if he goes after me, not one to just sit there and take his attack without strict challenge and "get off my back" from me. I just don't know if that would work though or if it would spiral into a bigger fight, that's what I'm concerned about, because if it did spiral, then I'm out of there fast or it's a bad fight for the whole family to see. It's like it's the wrong time to test the waters. His response to my letter manipulating me to try to go visit him was a reminder of where he "was" emotionally, and it, well, freaked me out, probably as it should. I just don't know, I'm trying to visualize his "best self" right now, but I don't know what I'll get if I go. I just think he dislikes me quite a bit, simply for not wanting to visit him, though instead of reaching out and telling me he'd love for me to visit and will respect boundaries, he instead threatens to remove me from his will if I don't visit (what a weird way to reach out). Then he wonders why I don't visit! (because I don't visit people who do those kinds of things!). I visit people who enjoy my company, yet allow me my freedom to visit or not visit. My parents I think feel I "owe" them. They feel like I haven't checked all the boxes in fulfilling my relation to them as an adult. But my policy is that I choose my own company, I'm not obligated to spend time with my father. I allow him his space and freedom, and I wish he would do the same for me. If you want something, set it free, if it returns, it's yours. He doesn't understand that. Yet I've never tried teaching it to him either, mostly because I don't think he would listen. I really don't think I've ever heard him say sorry to anyone ever, the more I think about it. There's a bit of guilt there too, kind of like I feel he just doesn't know better, so to him, I'm just being a bad son for staying away from him. I feel a bit guilty for choosing not to be around him because I don't think he truly understands why, yet I've never really had the ambition to work it out with him either. I just kind of moved on and hoped he would understand that I wanted a nice boundary. I just grew and didn't want to be around him, knowing how he is.

Anyways, thank you all for listening. I didn't realize I'd write so much, but it's been very therapeutic. I think you guys got a bit of what my diary entry would have included on this, how easy it is to open up to strangers! :-) I appreciate all your advice, it's been very helpful. My mom's stroke really brought these issues to the forefront, as these things usually happen with major events. I'm feeling stronger and will continue to work through this and see where it brings me, all the while keeping tabs with how my Mom's doing. So far, not great, but it's still early post-operation. All the best, KB.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report
NeedHelpWithMom Jun 2023
Hey, we are here to listen and support you. It does help to talk about our feelings as we sort through our emotions.

As I read this post, I can clearly see the struggle that you are having right now. Listen to your inner voice. Your instincts are telling you that your dad has major issues.

Of course, you are concerned about your mom. You’re also concerned about your own well being which is completely natural.

Check on your mom if you think that is best. Send her a card. Or send a message through the staff at the hospital.

Protect yourself from being hurt from your parents.
(2)
Report
kbuswave,

Welcome to the forum.

You will see that there are lots of people on this forum who have grown up in dysfunctional families.

Congrats on building a successful life for yourself. So many people normalize an unhealthy family life. They don’t realize how toxic it is until they move away and discover healthy relationships.

You knew that things were awful at home and found peace after you left.
Please don’t take a step backwards and place yourself in this situation again.

I am sorry that you have struggled with this situation. Your parents aren’t interested in repairing broken relationships.

So, as hard as it is, accept it because you don’t have the power to change it. If it is too painful for you to cut off all communication, do as others suggested and send cards.

Wishing you all the best. You deserve to be happy.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
kbuswave Jun 2023
"Please don’t take a step backwards and place yourself in this situation again."

Thank you. The above is precisely what I'm afraid of. I'm "out" right now, have been for a long time. I love my life. I don't want back in. Nice buffer zone. Before the stroke, I was happy with how things were. So from that vantage point, staying free and clear feels best and not overthinking it. I think I'm just prone to feel guilty easily, and when the stroke hit, so did the guilt if I don't go. Kind of like the child in me came back, "She's your mother, you better go, they're all expecting you, they'll think you're horrible if you don't." Back to square one for a while. Geez, I should be beyond that by now and not pay mind to those voices. I just don't want to feel as though I'm skirting my responsibilities somehow and not doing "what's right." (especially when the family 1000 miles away is likely thinking I'm doing everything wrong).
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Well. Another thing you could do is get in touch with the hospital's chaplaincy team, explain the background of family conflict and your concerns it might flare up if you were to visit, and ask if they would be able to mediate to allow you a private visit with your mother.

The first thing they'll do is ask her if she wants to see you, but they should have the tact to ask her this in private. If you do decide to ask for their support you will have to trust them to handle it, by the way. Don't start out by telling them what they should think of all the individuals involved.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

KB, read up on Fear, Obligation and Guilt. F.O.G.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

You have excellent insight and you should be very proud of your survival, and your strength in making yourself a good life.

To me your Mom was every bit as flawed and responsible as your Father. However, you seem to have insight in to "what will happen" and into the fact that they were so very flawed.

I think the way you have handled yourself, your life, your choices so far has been absolutely exemplary. I would be the last to advise you now and can only suggest that you do what will bring you the most peace. There will not be any deathbed reunion and you seem to know that.

Do what is best for YOU. You already know your parents were far too flawed to be decent parents; you know nothing will change that; you know you are a survivor.

I sure wish you the best and hope you'll update us.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
kbuswave Jun 2023
Thank you for this, and I will update.
(2)
Report
KB, just stop right there.

Why on EARTH would you move in with your weak, neurotic mother?

Are you trying to end your emotionally healthy way of living?

Please read this:

https://www.agingcare.com/discussions/if-you-are-going-to-become-a-caregiver-480769.htm?orderby=recent
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
kbuswave Jun 2023
I don't know, maybe out of obligation, I'm not there yet, it's a hypothetical for now if my dad were out of the picture, maybe I'd re-evaluate. My family is based on guilt. When I didn't go home for Xmas 20 years ago because I needed a bit of space, every member of my family told me how selfish I was, and when I arrived 3 days after Xmas, my father interrogated me because "I had made my mother cry." He abuses my mother every single day, yet blamed me for her tears because I came home late for Xmas by 3 days. That's why I left the family, I knew it was wrong, sick, but I barely knew how it should be because I had grown up in that family. Totally good now, just keep in touch with my mother, and now her stroke, so just feeling that dip in confidence that I'm still doing the right thing staying away from them because I feel guilty for not being there for my mother right now, even if I don't truly "like" her that much in the end. Just that feeling of obligation and being the "bad son" in my father's eyes, hearing his voice 1000 miles away. Feeling selfish, even though I know I have the right to not be around him. "How can I not go see my mom? She was there for you as a kid. You need to go and take your father's crap for her sake." That's the internal voice. Just processing it. This forum is helping a great deal, I needed some troops on my side. :-) Thank you.
(4)
Report
See 2 more replies
Send flowers and a card.

If you KNOW that your father will be around and get ugly, that will impact mom's health negatively.

I can't see any upside to visiting.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Well, my first thought is IF you do go (and you absolutely don’t have to), I would go abut 20 minutes before visiting hours are over so you don’t have to see your dad. Maybe work with an extended family member to help with this (though if your family is like mine, they are all messed up).

What do YOU want to do?

Don’t make a decision based on FOG (Fear, obligation guilt). Protect your peace.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report
kbuswave Jun 2023
Thank you, yes, I am currently in the FOG phase for sure. It's why I'm not currently planning on going, because I've long known that being motivated by that energy, no matter how tempting, is trouble in the end. Plus, my guardian angel here, my dog, is almost 11, and I hadn't wanted to vaccinate him again due to his age (I love him to death and take his health very seriously, I'm very careful about over-vaccinating), but would need to, to visit, because it's across the border. He's usually the one who comes between me and making poor decisions, and I think this is yet another example of that, otherwise I may have already gone and be making a mistake by impulse to get rid of the guilt I'm feeling about my mother and feeling like a "bad son" for not seeing my dad "for her sake." I feel sorry for my mother, and I know it would mean something to her to see me. The stroke was serious, she's just coming out of surgery and may be 1/2 body paralyzed, we don't know yet. I don't want her to want me there, but I know it would help her seeing my face even if she barely recognized me. When she was healthy, I had no trouble not visiting her, no guilt really, because she made her choices and I made mine. No problem. But now I'm feeling that "pull" toward compromise due to her weakened state and know I have the power to help her feel better just by seeing me. It's hard to hold her responsible for her decisions in moments like this, that's how I'm feeling. It's tough.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
I believe you are doing the right thing. Here's an idea: Have someone set up a Skype, Zoom or other similar meeting for you and your mom. It can be timed for when dad isn't there. If mom has lots of family around, surely someone would help you do this from your phone to mom's phone or relative's phone, or phone to computer - however you can make it work.

If she's going to rehab, your visit could wait for when she's there. The atmosphere is different from a hospital, and the staff might be able to help as part of mom's therapy.

It's not holding hands, but you'd get to see each other and it might life your spirits. Never give up your principle of taking no abuse. That's bedrock in your life.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
kbuswave Jun 2023
Thank you for this, and I agree, the skype or zoom would be a good idea. It would actually lift her spirits I'm sure. Yes, a few family members have reached out to ask if they can do anything, I could make that work. It just feels like it's so easy to feel guilty for anything less than showing up, but I'm working through that.
(2)
Report
You have to do what YOU feel is the "right thing" for you in this case. If going to visit mom will create an altercation with dad that may set your mom back from recovery, what's the point? Think of it that way. Plus, your mother made the choice to stay with the man all these years, knowing and tolerating his abusive behavior towards you, her son, which makes her an accomplice to it. Same as my father was to my mothers abusive behavior towards me. There's no excuse for it, and I lost respect for dad as a result. Our relationship suffered as a result over the years and never blossomed into a healthy one as one hopes to have with their parents.

Take care of yourself now. Send cards, flowers and make phone calls. Subjecting yourself to the toxic waste won't change the outcome of your mother's stroke, one way or another.

Best of luck to you.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
kbuswave Jun 2023
"Plus, your mother made the choice to stay with the man all these years, knowing and tolerating his abusive behavior towards you, her son, which makes her an accomplice to it."

The above is exactly why I'm having so much trouble truly "feeling it" for my mother right now. She allowed it because she was too weak to stand up for what's right and put a stop to it, even way back when. I remember feeling like I was in an asylum while in the family. I forgive her for that, but not to the extent that I'll take my father's guilt trips to be there for her. I don't trust my father emotionally under any circumstance and especially not now given he dislikes me enough to take me out of his will. I'm shaking while writing this, that's how hard all of this is, and I appreciate your response to send flowers and other responses as well to set up Zoom and such. I know my mother loves me, and I do love her, but the day I decided to free myself from my father's BS is the day I knew she wasn't able to support it because she would never recognize why I needed to be away from it (because she's been in that environment all her life, to her it was normal, but when I moved out I realized how healthy of a space I could create for myself and how messed up family life actually was, I've been living that better life for 20+ years now). I can't be around my father again until he recognizes it's not my fault for wanting to be away from him. That day will never come, that's fine. I just have to work around it so I can be there for my mother to some extent, not that I'm super close to her, but I know she's tried to love me the best she knows how and I respect that. I owe her that in return, so I'll try to love her the best I can, which is from a distance. She's clueless about the dynamic between my father and I, but do hold her in higher regard than him by a country mile. If my father died tomorrow, I'd move in with my mother and take care of her, but for now, her primary caregiver is my father. That was her choice a long time ago, despite me encouraging her to get away from him. I've long stopped taking responsibility for how my father treats his wife, which has been a healthy step for me. I just decided I wanted no part of being treated the same way. By the way, if I send flowers, or zoom, or have a plane fly overhead with a sign, my father's reaction will be "He doesn't even care enough to visit," which is precisely why I want nothing to do with him and won't go. That's how he doesn't respect boundaries. If I visit, then leave after two days, it'll be "Why leave so soon? Can't you see your mother needs you? You never visit and already you're leaving?" Interrogation. Just like the letter I sent him in good faith was followed up with "then if he appreciates me so much, why can't he even visit?" It's never, "Thank you son, I appreciate your kind gesture, let's build on this" and allowing a healthy boundary from which a relationship could grow. Instead, it was remove him from the will if he doesn't visit. The proof is in the pudding, and is exactly why I left a long time ago, hard as it was.
(3)
Report
See 3 more replies
I would go only if it is possible to see her when other family members are not present and you have no chance of running into them there or in the area. If her life isn't in danger then waiting until some of the drama has died down a bit might make that more achievable.
In the mean time send a card and/or a hospital friendly gift.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter