My mother has been living in my home for the past six years. She is in good shape financially and in relatively good shape physically. Her state of dementia is severe. Most of the time, having her here is doable. I am able to have a caregiver during the day for about five hours/day. The struggle is what is the right thing to do. I have always believed in the concept of caring for our ageing parents. When I read the comments from folks on this forum, I almost feel like a fool. It seems that most of what I read on this site encourages family members to put their LO in an appropriate facility. At times, when she is whining incessantly, and I just want some space, I think that a facility is the answer. Then, I agonize over how poorly it would work for her. She is needy, like a child needing constant attention. I had her in senior day care and she was kicked out because they couldn't give her the attention she was demanding. I know that she is happy here with me and my husband. Am I being an idiot for not putting her elsewhere? The internal struggle is so difficult because I know that having her here affects us all. My daughter, who has been here for the past year due to Covid, has really bonded with her grandmother. My daughter adores her grandmother and the time that she spends with her. The antics that my mother exhibits drives me crazy and my daughter is able to see humor and be compassionate. I can be that way much of the time, but then there are those days when she is going through her late afternoon craziness and I just want her gone. I know that she will continue to deteriorate. She has since I first moved her into my home. I just don't know what decision I can live with internally. For a little background, my father was dying and I drove him across the country and into a facility for his last month. He didn't want to die away from family. I saw him sporadically while he was still alive since it was an effort to find the time to be with him. That was two years ago. To this day, I suffer that I wasn't available for those final weeks. It haunts me. I don't want to feel that way with my mother.
Care giving someone is hard. Care giving someone with advanced dementia is nearly impossible to do. I am glad that you are getting 5 hours of help a day. And your daughter spends time with her too. That all helps make the situation somewhat livable although still quite difficult and demanding.
Can you talk with someone about this decision? Make yourself a pro/con chart? You don't have to do as much as humanly possible to be able to live with yourself without guilt. You deserve to have a life and freedom to be happy and spend your time in ways that benefit you.
Your mom is probably happier at your home. She's comfortable there, etc. BUT she is also a lot of work and as you know it is only going to get worse. 24/7 care is VERY demanding and you will get burnt out and suffer physically and/or mentally when you are doing too much.
I would start looking into places. Find one or two you like. If there's a waiting list, put her on it. You can always pass at the time and go back to the bottom of the list. When she has a bit of decline, that might be the proper time to move her into a facility.
Again, there are no right or wrong answers. You don't have to wait until you are beyond done. It is reasonable to put yourself on the list of important things and not just put your mom first in all cases. There are pros and cons to either option and do not beat yourself up about the cons of placing her somewhere. Nothing is perfect.
You need to forgive yourself regarding your dad. You did what you could at the time, what you thought was best. It's really not fair to second guess yourself. Even if your solution wasn't perfect, nothing really is so give yourself permission to be an imperfect human being. Like the rest of us.
Your response about being a "burned out caregiver" is me all over x
Remember, if you decide to relocate your mom, that although she may no longer be in your direct care, you are still caring for her ( and yourself) in providing her a safe, comfortable environment where the staff is trained to provide for her well being.
Hi- do you have a source for this info by any chance? TIA!
My girls saw humor in the situation too, but they weren't here 24/7. They weren't bathing, dressing and toileting her. Mom could do nothing for herself other than feeding herself. Itvwas like having a toddler again.
Like, but not... Although my kids were both on the larger side at birth (son was almost 9.5lbs! and I'm like 5'2", about 110lbs before pregnancy!) they certainly were not ADULT sized! Being a senior myself at the time with some physical limitations, there's no way I could provide the care needed for a 140lb "toddler"!
My mother's place was always coming up with activities, mostly in situ, but some outings as well, for those who could still manage them. Any time I visited (varied day and time, no warning to staff!), mom was clean, well fed and relatively happy. While she wouldn't participate in some activities (light exercise, oh no, I did that for years, I don't need to do that now!), most of the time she would join in.
Socialization is something that is recommended, to help keep the LO "stimulated" and active. One person at home doing ALL the tasks needed can't possibly keep the LO entertained most of the day! It is one of the benefits of choosing to use a facility. There are perks either way, depending on resources available. So it comes down to finances and how long one can continue to give every day. There's no real right or wrong choice, but all too often the choices are limited.
"It seems that most of what I read on this site encourages family members to put their LO in an appropriate facility."
This recommendation should be reserved for those who are at the end of their rope, or will be soon. One person trying to do everything is going to burnout. The problem is many don't have the financial resources to pay for a facility and the LO doesn't qualify for Medicaid (most states don't cover AL/MC, many with dementia don't qualify for NHs.) For those who have help and want to do it, it might be better to keep the LO at home. For those who don't, one person can't do it all.
"At times, when she is whining incessantly, and I just want some space, I think that a facility is the answer."
Again, this may be resolved by increasing caregiver time. You mention late afternoon tends to be meltdown time. Consider some mild medication to help with this. Sun-downing is VERY common and generally occurs later afternoon. There are non-medication suggestions, but often those don't work well enough. The only time my mother was "out of control" late afternoon/early evening was due to a UTI. Antibiotics and low dose Lorazepam (during treatment only) took care of that.
"I know that she is happy here with me and my husband. Am I being an idiot for not putting her elsewhere?"
No, you're not an idiot for keeping her home. It's a struggle to know what's best, but if you can get someone who can help "entertain" her and find ways to keep her busy, it can still work. You need time for yourself, time to get out, do things YOU enjoy and be away from her "neediness". It's in many ways like having a toddler, but different. It can get under your skin, the repetition, the unending help she needs with ADLs, etc. The key is having the right resources to help. Since you say she's relatively healthy and okay financially, perhaps bringing in more assistance will help.
"My daughter, who has been here for the past year due to Covid, has really bonded with her grandmother. My daughter adores her grandmother and the time that she spends with her. The antics that my mother exhibits drives me crazy and my daughter is able to see humor and be compassionate."
That's a big help! Given they get along and she enjoys spending time with her takes some load off you. My grandmother (no dementia) lived with us part of the time and with my mother's sisters. I appreciated the time I had with her. Dementia puts a wrinkle into care, and it's too much for one person. With the right help it can work. Something staff suggests - rather than letting her antics annoy you, join her in the "moment" if you can. Sometimes there can be some humor in it.
"I know that she will continue to deteriorate."
She'll regress in time. She'll have more difficulty getting around and doing for herself. I'm a senior with physical limitations, and my house isn't safe for my mother to have lived in. Instead I found the best place for her, managed her affairs and visited as often as I could. At some point she may become bedridden. That'll require a lot more in-home care or a facility. When you really feel the care you and help can provide isn't working, then a facility might be the answer.
"To this day, I suffer that I wasn't available for those final weeks. It haunts me. I don't want to feel that way with my mother."
This is also a personal dilemma. My mother wasn't close enough for me to check on her daily or provide the care she needed. Hiring help didn't work, as she considered herself "fine" and refused to let them in. I selected a place close to where I live so that I could monitor her care and be there for her.
Some of mine are when...
- it makes no difference to them as to where they are or who is caring for them;
- I start to feel their (or my) safety is placed at risk (through behavior or lost communication);
- they become confined to bed/wheelchair;
- (sadly) my own tolerance fails to rebound over several days in a row.
Of course, in your situation you need to factor in the positives of your daughter's compassion and glean some of her inspiration - it sounds mutually beneficial despite the sacrifices (and you are unwittingly a role model for her also) - but when you feel your mother will receive better care elsewhere, you'll be best to follow through.
Folks who hang out here are the ones who are having problems-- either the elder is mentally ill, needs much more care than can be given at home, is unsafe due to wandering or causing fires, threatening physical violence.
Or they are simply folks who aren't cut out to be caregivers, have been guilted or shamed into giving up their livelihood and/or home, or who have had an elder "dumped" on them.
You are not a fool! Caregiving for a parent at home can be wonderful, if you have the space, aptitude and help required.
My personal take is that many elders thrive in congregate settings with multiple people to interact with and professional medical oversight. To each his own.
I later changed my thought process to "I will keep him at home as long as it is safe for HIM for me to care for him at home AND as long as it is safe for ME to care for him at home."
Thankfully with the help of Hospice and the VA I was able to keep him at home.
Thankfully he was also VERY easy to care for he was always compliant. And luckily or not with each "problem" that came along there seemed to be a solution that came with it.
So base your thought process on safety
Is it safe for HER that you are a caring for her in your home?
Is it safe for YOU that you are caring for her in your home?
Do you have Hospice in that will provide you with all the equipment and supplies you need? I can tell you right now without the equipment I got from Hospice I would have had to place my Husband. A Sit To Stand was a lifesaver (and back saver) then progressing to a Hoyer Lift.
I also said with many decisions I made about my Husband I was ruled by 2 organs. My Head and my Heart.
Safety is a Head decision.
Letting her eat a candy bar when she really shouldn't that is a Heart decision.
The first pain is the loss of your father. Since your lack of availability still haunts you, please consider dealing with this pain that is over a year in suffering. May I suggest attending a grief group like GriefShare. The members of the group are all experiencing loss of a loved one or stay to help others through the journey they have already taken. If groups are not your "thing", consider meeting regularly with a counsellor. Counsellors are available to meet online and in person. Check either with your doctor or community of faith for suggested counsellors.
Your second pain is seeing your mother deteriorate. You remember the vibrant woman who met the needs of others - specifically you. Please consider researching about the type of dementia your mother has (the one the doctor diagnosed). Alzheimer's disease and Parkinson's disease is progressive. Stroke type dementia tends to remain stable. With information, you can plan for your mother's care over the course of her lifespan with her healthcare providers and your family. You are not in this alone. If you feel lingering sadness over her decline, please process this with a counsellor.
Managing your mom's problems. Her memory loss can cause her to have anxiety which leads to antics. Please have her evaluated for anxiety by her doctor or a geriatric psychiatrist. One of them may prescribe her anti-anxiety medications that should help with taking the edge off her anxiety. A consistent routine will also help. Her afternoon episodes are usually called Sundowner's syndrome. With Sundowner's, the sufferer is more anxious as the daylight wanes and things don't look the same. This coupled with increasing tiredness make anxiety levels rise and folks are apt to act out. The anti-anxiety medication should help as as consistent routine and more light in the afternoon/evening. You will know it is time for another caregiving option when the needs of the family, your marriage, and your relationship can not be met since every moment is spent caring for your mom. If you sense rising resentment in yourself or your family members, consider it a sign of burnout and that something must change.
When a loved one is sent to a home, it's like a death sentence. If the old person acts out or in your mom's case is needy, they just give them meds to make it easier on the Caregivers.
No loved one would want to go to an unfamiliar place that is basically only in it for the money. Sure you may be lucky enough to have a rare Caregiver that really cares but their far and few between as Caregivers get burnt out.
Your mom being at your home, is the safest, happiest, loving place she could be.
No one should die alone.
It is hard being a Caregiver but in your case your mom has money, spend it on your mom and hire as much in home help as you need to not feel overwhelmed.
You are deffiently doing the Right Thing by your mom.
You won't have any regrets in the end.
It's so sad for people to just send their loved ones away when they need them the most.
Bring in familiar surroundings is so important for people with Dementia and even in the end when they remember less and less, and may not even remember your name or who you are, they know a friendly loving face and it makes them feel loved and safe.
Prayers
Caregiving is very hard, and it is stressful...but I never regretted it. Mom was my entire universe. I love her dearly. And mom never did suffer...she was very peaceful and was on hospice for two years. They were great supplying me with diapers, bed protector pads, tube feeding, tubing, feeding pump, hospital bed, table, oxygen, and whatever else I needed. But I did all the care. We never had to open that "comfort pack" and her death was the most peaceful you can ever imagine. She never needed any narcotics or psychotropics and hospice came over daily when she was actively dying.
I walked mom everyday for five years. She loved the park. She had a special walker. TO this day I look at that park and I sink into a mourning remembering walking her daily. I miss her terribly and it's been 1-1/2 years ago she died.
Even with the twilight of her life, I kept her comfortable and I worked hard to sustain her. That is something I can carry with me the rest of my life. I did my duty caring for her, and she had a good life even with AD.
YOU have to anticipate what I went through and you need to learn how to care for someone who will become 100% dependent on you. Be mindful eventually they will forget how to eat and drink, and it can take two weeks to die of dehydration. And they will be awake if you go no feeding tube route, even on hospice. That is something you and your family need to talk about, but only use that as a LAST RESORT. Feeding tubes need a LOT of care, and not to be taken lightly. It took me over an hour to feed my mom before that. And I had to give her thickened fluids one teaspoon at a time. That took hours. I did this all day long. Now mom never bothered her tube. I still kept it covered with a tube top (for comfort) to prevent pulling on it while turning and cleaning her. Her feeding tube required a LOT of care to prevent infection and the tube patent. Most people cannot handle that.
Nursing home is a tough decision. Most Asians care for their own folks. That's part of our culture. I know most Americans do nursing homes. I took care of my mom at home since that's an Asian thing to do.
I'm wondering if your mom is experiencing sundowning later in the day. Perhaps her doctor can help her with this; I've heard that light therapy before 7 pm may be of help.
I write from the patients point of view. I was diagnosed with Early Onset ALZ in June of 2016. Most recently my Neuropsych Exam, said I've moved to Moderate to Severe Dementia. My DW and I disagree with the results and we have an appointment to discuss the results with the Doctor in early June. The Doctor says I should have 24/7 care, my DW and I agree I've moved in to the middle stages, but not severe needing 24/7 care.
I've told my DW and all four of my children ranging from 40-14, that when I am at the point that I can no longer participate in the day to day activities of helping out in the house then it is time to put me in a MC or Skilled Nursing Facility. I also contend I want to be placed 100mi away from our home so that my DW and children don't think they have to visit me every day. My DW is 8 yrs younger than me and I want her to go about living life.
Two of our three children live in other states leaving our oldest in his mid 20's living at home and our 14 yr old. My oldest 40 lives in another state he agrees with my position we talk, but have rarely seen him over the last 15 yrs. I've told all three of my adult children, when it's time for me to go in to a MC facility, let mom do what she want's to go on with life and don't give her any grief if she wants to date, or divorce me and remarry. Our two 20 somethings understand, I don't think the 14 yr old is ready to hear this, but we'll tell her when we feel she's ready. We've enjoyed 27yrs together married and dating. She has a lot to offer another man. and I want her to enjoy the rest of her life. She's never had any medical issues, we've practiced our faith ever since we started dating.
My point is that, you must do what is in the best interest of you your DH and children, and what you believe is right for your mother. Do not let outside influences lead you down a path you don't want to walk on. I watched my maternal uncle who was a Priest die from ALZ and my stepfather die from ALZ, they both were in MC Facilities. I know they received the best of care and were placed in the best place for themselves. The difference is one of my sisters worked in the facility my uncle was in, and my stepsister, lived near my stepfather. They were still both worn in to the ground. I don't want that for my family, and I've shared these thoughts for more that 20yrs, so this is not jibber-jabber on my part. I want my DW and family to thrive. I hope you find this comment helpful.
Big decisions take time to work through. Spend some quality time with yourself weighing all the facts, considering EVERYONE involved, and looking into the future with the different possible scenarios. I think you will make the right decision.
You already suffer regret over dad so you would probably have same issue over mom. Use her money to give you a little peace for as long as you can.
In retrospect, wish I had put her in diapers and kept her home a little longer. While in the SNF, I continued to take care of her hair. After her Tuesday shower, I would come and “roll her hair” and put her under the hair dryer plus cut and clean her nails that were often dark with poop. I don’t know how I could have managed her health/doctoring if she had stayed home with me. If I thought a UTI had returned, I would find the nurse practitioner and tell her. Easy. The negative side: they left her in her wheelchair after meals instead of putting her in bed. She had lost the ability to sit up. I walked in several times to find her sliding out of her chair. She also had skin injuries on her legs.
Hindsight vision: I wish I had given up on the bedside potty and diapered her and protected her bed appropriately. Because she was bedfast, she was not a danger to herself. I could have kept her home a little longer.