Follow
Share

I was recently hospitalized for a few days and I texted my sister to let her know. She asked if I wanted her to come to my town, several hours away from her. I said if she wanted to, it would be helpful and she could stay with my mom. My mom was in my room at the hospital and my sister and brother arrived. They planned for my sister to spend the night with my mom and left pretty soon after.
I texted my sister the next asking when they were coming up and she never answered. Eventually my brother texted me and said that my sister had gotten in a fight with my mom and left after 30 minutes and drove back to her house, 4 hours away. As she left, she told my mom she Hopes she (mom) dies and that she's all alone. My sister eventually texted me and said I need to get my phone off her cell plan and that she wants nothing to do with me as I am a connection to our mother. All of this as I am laying in a hospital bed. Any thoughts on this? All she had to do was go to sleep and bring my mom up to the hospital the next day. I didnt ask or pressure her to come. I don't get it.

😪 You're in hospital & your family are warring each other? Shame on them.

Best recovery to you 🤗

May be staff be supportive, the treatment easy & the food as tolerable as hospital food can be.
Helpful Answer (9)
Reply to Beatty
Report

I would grant your sister's request and have nothing more to do with her ever. Block her phone number, block her on social media etc and go stone cold silent about anything and everything. Don't mention the fight to your mother and let that remain between them. If it gets mentioned don't play "peace maker". Don't bring it up with your brother etc. ever again. My mother and sister do this all the time, and I stay out of it. When you find a big pot of crazy it's best not to stir it.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to Jhalldenton
Report
EmotionallyNumb Sep 11, 2024
I can do that, its not like she is a daily part of my life. It is sad that our family is turning out this way.
(2)
Report
I read your original post from 2018. JoAnn in the comments posted the link to it.

Your mother was in agonizing pain and had dementia back then. You were at the end of your rope with her back in 2018. Surely her conditions have gotten worse over the years and yet the situation remains the same.

Why is she not in a nursing home or a memory care facility?

You say you were hospitalized for a few days. I'm sorry to hear it and I hope you're fully recovered. Surely someone stayed with your mother for those days.

You say your mother was in your hospital room when your brother and sister arrived. How did she get there if she's disabled and has dementia? Who was supposed to elder-sit her in the hospital.

With all due respect to you, I think you've made yourself into a care martyr and you're angry because your sister has not. You've been posting here with basically the same complaining since 2018 yet you take no action to change the caregiving dynamic in your family. Your mother needs to be placed in facility care and you need to make your own life.

Why are you on your sister's cellphone plan? You're an adult. Grow up and go get your own. Your sister should grow up as well and not be so petty with the threats to cut you off the phone plan.

Make some plans for yourself. Your mother should be placed in care so you can make a life for yourself. One where you're not dependent on a sibling for a phone or a sik, aging parent for housing. You deserve to have a life. You've been in this family dynamic for years now. It's time to change it and the change starts with you.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report
EmotionallyNumb Sep 11, 2024
I am afraid you have some incorrect viewpoints of this situation. First off, I do not live in my mother's home and I am fully employed. I pay all the bills. my sister offered for me to have a line on her phone plan a few years ago as it was $10 a month.

I may have been angry at one point with my siblings for not helping with my mom but I dont think that I am anymore, every one has a choice and I may think its crappy but it's their choice.

My mom is actually doing pretty good, she's had several surgeries to help with her health issues and the dementia has been fairly stable. I moved about eight months ago and we've actually been getting along pretty good since then.
(0)
Report
See 4 more replies
I think a lot of times relatives pick fights with the caregiver so they won't have to help out. Happened in my family.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to katiekat2009
Report

Obviously your sister’s issues with your mother are complex. Who knows what went on between them when she was young. it damages a child and she orobsbly blames you for how it was when you were growing up.

Im going through this with my sister. She had a lousy relationship with our mother and now that our mother is gone she has distanced herself from me.

I don’t know if this can be fixed in your situation. You can try to talk to her. Maybe suggest getting some counseling to try to save your relationship.

In my case I was sad about our rift 30 years ago. We came together to help our parents but after our mother died in June she distanced herself. I’m now apathetic about my relationship with her. It really doesn’t matter to me if she is in my life or not.

I hope you can salvage your relationship with her but don’t hold your breath. Just tell her that you are there for her in case she changes her mind.I hope it works out for you.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report
EmotionallyNumb Sep 11, 2024
They do have relationship issues. I just dont understand how she couldn't put that aside for one night because I had a serious illness and that has never happened before. Then no contact with me bc of her relationship with mom ? All BS. I dont plan to reach out to her after being treated like this. But how do you tell your mom you hope she dies? I can't imagine a situation in which that is ok. She doesnt help with mom at all.
(0)
Report
See 2 more replies
I am afraid that you do get it now, though, don't you?
I doubt that this is a new condition. Or am I wrong? Did your mother and sister get along all the time and this is some sudden new change? Or has there been ongoing stress between Sis and Mom?

I am sorry, but you can't pick your relatives. Mom and Sis, despite your being hospitalized could not get along, and if mom requires someone with her 24/7 (does she?) then sis was negligent to leave her in that manner because of a bicker.

There is of course nothing we here can do about this. This is something you now know. It is no longer option to speak with sister about your mother, so please do not do so.
I am very sorry. But as they say "them's the facts". Your sis and your mom don't like one another and don't wish to see one another.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report
EmotionallyNumb Sep 11, 2024
No, they havent gotten along well for a long time. I havent talked to my sister about my mom for a long time bc she will try to use anything I say against my mom. I just didnt thi k my sister would reduce our relationship to my being a 'connection' to our mom. Or bc I won't do what she wants and put my mom in sad little nursing home and never visit her.
(0)
Report
See 1 more reply
Boy I would love to know what those two said to each other.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to olddude
Report
EmotionallyNumb Sep 11, 2024
My mom told me some of it, apparently it started off with mom making a political comment and my sister said she didnt want to talk about that, then they sat in silence on the ride home from the hospital. Once home, they started talking about past issues. Sister said mom was a bad mom and accused her of calling CPS on her 20 years ago, which never happened. Mom asked sister if she had told her kids different things, like alienating type of things. It culminated with sister standing by the door yelling 'I hope you die and now you're all alone'.
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
I also want to add, in family's, 2 siblings can be raised but have completely different versions of there store.

Age, experience, parents tend to treat one sibling differently than others.

Sometimes talking to siblings you may even wonder if they where raised in the same house.

You do sound, frustrated but much more emotionally mature than some posters I've read . So kudo's for that, and best of luck.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to Anxietynacy
Report
BurntCaregiver Sep 11, 2024
@Anxietynacy

I hear that!
(3)
Report
See 1 more reply
Sister is perhaps having issues nothing to do with you or mom but old traumas triggered her when she was with your mom? Was she okay when you saw her in your hospital room?

She obviously wanted to help or wouldn’t have driven 8 hrs to try.

I would give her a pass at this point. You have your own health to deal with and now know that you need a backup plan for mom.

Perhaps when you are well and she has some distance from mom you can let her know you are sorry it didn’t work out. That extreme a reaction makes me think she needs some therapy or perhaps she has a UTI, on some new meds, beginning’s of dementia, menopausal, bipolar or something else leaving her no reserve to deal with her mom.

I remember how you helped with your cousins and aunt and extended family. Am I remembering correctly that you are a social worker? It is not unusual, perhaps common, for those who have dealt with trauma to pass it on to their children. Not that they want to. Your experience with mom is obviously very different from sisters. You, perhaps because of your work, may have had more opportunity to process the little bumps in the road of life. For sure you have had more time with mom.

Get well soon and good to hear from you. It really seems your sis is not in a good place. I would wait and see before writing her off.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to 97yroldmom
Report
EmotionallyNumb Sep 12, 2024
Sis has a history of a temper and outbursts. It has been better over the last few years but when I think about it, it's been a long time since she was actually alone with mom. I dont really like being around the two of them together bc it's a lot tension and I am usually nervous they are going to get in a fight. How do I navigate that and continue to not take sides bc 99% have nothing to do with me?
(1)
Report
See 3 more replies
One guess might be that your M praised you to S and ran down S to her face compared to you. That could explain S’s anger at both you and M. If that might make sense, you have a choice about whether or not to try to make things up with S, for the benefit of the rest of your lives.

You aren’t unreasonable about being fed up with her behavior when you were in trouble, but obviously S was very upset about what was said almost immediately in that meeting with M. A four hour trip in each direction proves that it was a very bad trip for S, and the chances are that M was at least as much at fault.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to MargaretMcKen
Report
EmotionallyNumb Sep 11, 2024
Oh I'm sure my mom gave as good as she got, she's definitely not a shrinking violet. But that is their fight and their dynamic, it shouldn't impact my relationship with either of them. I stopped taking sides in their fights a long time ago, which bugs both of them.

I dont know if I will try to have a relationship with her in the future. If this is how she treats me when I'm in one of the most vulnerable times of my life than maybe it isn't a relationship worth trying to save.
(3)
Report
See 2 more replies
See All Answers
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter