Follow
Share

My sister was granted conservator for our mom who was diagnosed with dementia our mother passed away 2 years later. She had all conservator records sealed after a judge granted records to be unsealed. I discovered that she paid herself almost 8K a month she charged our mother rent , exterminator service, lawn service, laundry service, groceries, meds. Also misc items. My sister also had a tiny house built on her property for 15K for supposedly our mother to live in. Can she legally do this seems extremely excessive she received 96K a year out of our mother's funds. I already have a attorney was just curious on some feedback. The State is Georgia.

Find Care & Housing
What law would prohibit this? While it may be morally questionable, I don't think it's against the law. What did your lawyer say? Here is what Google says:

Yes, it is 100% legal to be a landlord. Yes, landlords can rent to people in their family. Yes, landlords can charge whatever rent they want, and even forgive rent payments as they see fit.

Where were you while all this was going on? And why now are you trying to sue (I guess) your sister, or penalize her in some way? Why did you not care for your mother with dementia instead?

Makes me glad I was an only child, tbh, when I read all these stories about sibling wars. It's very sad.

My condolences on the loss of your mother.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to lealonnie1
Report

Darlas50, welcome to the forum. So sorry for your loss. Please fill out the Profile page to help us get a better understanding. Example, what stage of dementia was your Mom when she went to live with your sister? Did she have other medical/physical issues?


Since your Mom lived with your sister, it sounds like your sister was your Mom caregiver 24/7 which can be physically and emotionally exhausting. It is not uncommon for a grown child to charge "rent" as having another person living in the house is added expense. Plus a grown child should NOT be using their own money to pay for things a parent needs, especially if the parent can afford to pay for her own groceries, medicine, personal care products, laundry, clothing, eyeglasses, etc.


When my Dad needed caregivers, he hired 3-shifts for each and every day. The cost was $20,000 per month, which works out to be $240,000 per year for our area. And that doesn't count the cost Dad paid for groceries, medicine, personal care products, laundry, eyeglasses, etc.

You mentioned you hired an Attorney. Is this Attorney an Elder Law Attorney?
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to freqflyer
Report

Was conservator court appointed? If so, she had to answer to the court. If a Judge did not feel the expenditure was over the top, then I guess whatvshe did was legal.
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to JoAnn29
Report

So two (2) years since your mom died? And now you want to challenge spending paid by your mom prior to her death?

What is the precise status on mom’s Estate? Like there was a will and it has been entered into probate? Who is named to be Executor and have they been issued Letters Testamentary? So Your attorney is a probate attorney who actually does litigation regularly in county where her probate has been filed and doing a “challenge” is still within however GA probate laws are administered?
OR
Mom died intestate? If so what has happened to deal with her estate? Does your atty do intestate work?
OR
Nothing has been done / opened at the courthouse AND your mom died with no house, land, cars or anything that could be considered real property of her ownership that requires a legal way to transfer title and do a distribution after death? Maybe mom died leaving a few thousand in her bank? But other than this, no “estate”? If this is the scenario, personally I think too too much time has passed to challenge spending your Sister did as a court appointed conservator. A few thousand in a bank account tends to be assumed to be funeral / burial related costs.

Why did you not file to become your mom’s conservator?

8K mo including any medical and drug copays isn’t excessive. In many parts of the US thats lower end for custodial care costs w/oversight.

Again, why did you not file to become your mom’s conservator years ago? If there were any issues that would call in question your or your household’s suitability to be a conservator, pls realize all this and in detail can come up if you try to sue Sissy. If there are skeletons in closet….. kids with juvee records, you or hubs were on any “at need” programs, crappy credit score, not working full time or lower end SSA retirement income, anyone in the household with DUI or other legal nonnice stuff, etc all easy to unearth.

If Sissy was court appointed, fwiw imo if you persue this, it is saying the judge who appointed her as conservator for years did not know what they were doing, that they were an idiot. It’s not a good look for you to present in a courtroom. Just sayin’.
Helpful Answer (5)
Reply to igloo572
Report
BurntCaregiver Jul 29, 2024
@igloo

Have you overlooked the most common reason why the OP is in the lawyer's office today over the money and why she didn't take on the caregiving duties?

The usual reason is the family member wants the money but doesn't want any of the caregiving responsibility.

I believe that's calling wanting to have your cake and eat it too.
(2)
Report
I feel like if your sister was your moms 24/7 caregiver, she deserves it. I'm so sorry, but this is hard work! I myself could never handle 24/7 care for someone.

And if one of my family members said they would do it for my mom, 24/7 and I new mom was safe and happier than being in a facility, it would be priceless to me
Helpful Answer (2)
Reply to Anxietynacy
Report

8.000 a month would be a large amount if charged by an ALF where the senior was somewhat mentally and physically capable, but would be a LOW cost for a memory care facility. As it is, your sister kept your Mother out of memory care. There she would have likely paid about 20,000 a month. If an attorney is charging you and is suggesting that this money is retrievable I think you are perhaps putting bad money after good. Your sister almost certainly had an attorney help her with a care contract. I would say that she was probably within her rights if your mother was able to afford this, and that she made your mother's last years happy and comfortable. I think perhaps it is time for you to move on from this issue. I wish you the best.
Helpful Answer (3)
Reply to AlvaDeer
Report

I was a Guardian for my Husband. (long story...)
But EVERY expense that I had for him was documented and it had to have been approved by the court.
I was able to "charge" him rent, food, part of the cable, phone, electricity, gas, water, paper, mortgage, insurance and on and on and on.
And I did NOT charge him for "caregiving" (now that I think about it I probably should have asked about that!)
If there was ANY expense that did not "ring true" it was rejected and I had to resubmit the month's budget work to the Court and I had to write a check from my account to "reimburse" him until it was approved.
So my guess is your sister went through the same thing I did. If the $8000 a month was approved then she had documentation to prove those expenses.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report
BurntCaregiver Jul 29, 2024
@Grandma

You could have charged him for caregiving. If your husband wasn't put into a care facility why it is anyone's business what goes on between the wife and husband?
(0)
Report
Why does $8 thousand a month seem extremely excessive to you? If your mother was in a nursing home or memory care facility the monthly bill would be far higher than 8 grand a month.

Your sister provided round-the-clock care along with safety and security measures for your mother. Your mother basically had her own private 'assisted living' residence on your sister's property also.

I'd say that 8 thousand a month was a pretty good deal considering what your mother was getting for it.

Would you feel better about the money if it was being given over to some nasty, gross, understaffed nursing home or memory care facility? You live in Georgia. Nice state. The cost of living is a little less than where I am in the northeast. Even with things costing a bit less, as far as nursing homes and memory care facilities go, your mother would be getting sub-par quality care for that money.

Your sister did right by your mother. Be glad of it. I did homecare for 25 years. Trust me, your sister did not have it easy. Be grateful that your sister made your mother's final years decent. She earned that money.

F.Y.I. The 8K a month is not considering "gifting" unless your mother went into a long-term care facility and Medicaid was applied for. So you going to a lawyer is only going to make your wallet a whole lot lighter for nothing because your sister did nothing wrong.
Helpful Answer (6)
Reply to BurntCaregiver
Report

Your sister taking care of your mother with dementia would be a LOT of exhausting work, plus 8000$ is a deal compared to Memory Care monthly costs. If she had to quit her job to help mom, that income would be even more necessary.

Having a loved one with dementia being taken care of by someone else is a huge, tremendous gift. Accept this gift as is and let the expenditure inquiries go.
Helpful Answer (4)
Reply to Madisoncuckoo7
Report

@Burnt as I said it is a long story and part of it was my "fault". I was made Guardian as I was not on any of the property he had and since he was not competent to make decisions according to the "Elder Care Attorney" I had I was told my only option was Guardianship.
Maybe had I pushed when we married to be put on property titles but he had been burned by his ex, the only reason he had what he had was because it was his before they had married so she could not get to it.
Prime example why I tell people to get their "legal ducks in a row" before it gets to a point where options are limited or impossible.
Helpful Answer (1)
Reply to Grandma1954
Report
BurntCaregiver Jul 30, 2024
I hear that, Grandma 1954. My husband and I put all of our legal ducks in a row before we remarried. Neither of us will put any kind of complication or difficulties on our kid either.
(1)
Report
Your sister was decent, she took care of mom. This was a huge sacrifice on her part. Why do you want begrudge her that money? It is more than reasonable. Did you expect her to do it for free? Where were you during those years?

You should thank her for her sacrifice.
Helpful Answer (0)
Reply to Hothouseflower
Report

Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter