Follow
Share

Mom, diagnosed with Alzheimer’s, has been in MC for about five months now. She is adjusting well and tells me she really enjoys the games, piano concerts, sightseeing rides and other activities there. She also seems less agitated and less prone to the delusions she used to have, and more capable overall (i.e., she can read and choose from a menu, whereas she couldn’t before ) even though she often can’t remember certain information from one minute to the next.


The one delusion she will not let go of, however, is the notion that my husband stole some Christmas cards from her months ago. She has confronted him angrily about this imagined theft in the past and said he was not welcome in her home, and although she does not bring it up anymore, my husband is still so put out about this that he has refused to spend time with her. They never really got along in the first place, but because of this estrangement I find myself having to split my free time between them while I keep them apart. It’s tiring and depressing trying to provide a one-person family experience for my mom, and my husband can’t seem to accept that it was the disease talking when she accused him. He points out that she was always paranoid and mistrustful (which is true). Should I try to insist he get over it and join me in spending time with her, or just assume I will have to keep them apart forever? In other situations I’ve known it seems as if married couples share the responsibility for an ill parent. I don’t really appreciate being left on my own with this, but at the same time I believe people have a right to avoid being subjected to hostility and insults. Mom will be joining us on Thanksgiving and Christmas, the first time in months we will be together, but my husband is accepting this only because of the holiday.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
My mother (with dementia) got mad at my husband a couple of years ago. She told him if she could poison him, she would gladly go to prison. He got over it because he knows it was her broken brain talking, and she doesn't remember it anyway. That was only one incident of her saying really ridiculous things. It has actually helped to make a joke out of it and laugh about the whole nonsense. Like for instance: "Well of course he stole her Christmas cards, because there is nothing he would rather have than Christmas cards that belong to an old lady," (extreme sarcasm implied). Get as ridiculous as you can possibly think and have a good laugh. One day when my sister told mom she needed to take a shower, mom told sister that she would take her out with Judo because she had been taking lessons. My youngest son said he would pay good money to see that. Another good laugh.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I think it may be hard to expect him to be around her. It’s not just the Alzheimer’s. You wrote that she was always paranoid and distrustful.

Personally I do not expect my husband to help with my Mom and he was not real close to my Dad. I’m very close to my MIL and FIL. Now that they’re traveling, I miss them.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

You cannot reason with someone with dementia. My mother was convinced my brother was having an affair with one of her aides, patently untrue. An aunt turned against her sister who had been her best friend for 90 years and refused to speak to her.

Perhaps you can convince your husband that she cannot help herself, it's the disease talking, her brain is broken. Buy some cards and have him give them to her and apologize. The world will not end and maybe everyone will have some peace. And yes, your husband is acting like a petulant child.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
MargaretMcKen Nov 2021
Come on now, husband is agreeing to his MIL coming to their house for the festive celebrations, MIL is in a NH, and he just doesn't want to join his wife in her visits to the NH. Sounds totally reasonable, and not at all like a 'petulant child'.
(4)
Report
See 1 more reply
Squid62: Per chance at these holiday gatherings it would be a good time to make amends.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report
Midkid58 Nov 2021
I know I already said my bit on this subject---but--the holidays are notoriously stressful and not calm, not one bit. I'm only cooking a small meal for ONE of my families today and I am already feeling the tension of pulling together a meal--when it's something I do EVERYDAY.

So--making this a time to make amends? I cannot even imagine that. My MIL will bring up ALL THE TIMES I made her mad at OTHER holiday events.

I'd wade those waters carefully. Well, actually, I wouldn't put myself in a position to even BE in the waters. I will not see my mother nor my MIL today. Will probably visit mother tomorrow, if I feel like it. DH will say he needs to call his mom and won't do it.

Holidays are stressful enough w/o dragging 45 years of past garbage out to examine and talk about.

Life is not a Hallmark movie.
(4)
Report
To be blunt it sounds like your husband is acting like a petulant child.
Many people with dementia have been exhibiting signs for sometimes up to 10 years before an actual diagnosis. Is this maybe one of the reasons your mom has been paranoid and mistrustful?
There is no need to "split your time" between your husband and your mom. Visit mom during the day, and it does not have to be everyday. And the rest of the time is yours to do with what you want. I am assuming that you have dinner with your husband, spend the evening, go to bed, wake up with him, have breakfast and begin your day. If you visit mom for 1 or 2 hours a few days a week that is far from "splitting time"
In any case
When mom visits I would keep the visit easy going, not a big crowd.
If mom starts in on your husband let him go watch a football game or read a book. No sense in both of them getting upset, making you upset in turn.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Isthisrealyreal Nov 2021
Thats not really fair to the husband, considering that they never really got along.
(3)
Report
I think you should be delirious with joy that your husband is willing to join her on the upcoing holiday. It's not as if she ever was really fond of him. No reason to throw the man under bus at this point of the game. Her brain is broken - it doesn't work the way it used to and she may or may not forgive him for the imagined theft. You have placed her in MC which she enjoys and where she is receiving good care. You should now enjoy some quality time with your husband. And quitely frankly, if Mom "misbehaves" during Thanksgiving, I would not ask my husband to submit himself to the possibility of the same behavior on Christmas. She may not remember how she has behaved but he does and he counts.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

This should probably be the last holiday season with Mom coming home, so bless your husband for putting up with it one more time. (Not that Mom's going to die, but taking her out of MC will likely be confusing and upsetting for her. It's easier to commemorate the holidays with her at her place on the date of your choosing.)

My husband got along just fine with my mom, but I don't think he saw her for at least the last 18 months of her life. He was just one more person she wouldn't quite recall, so we didn't push it.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

I had to tell my cousin I couldn't invite her to Thanksgiving and Christmas any more, because my husband thinks she stole his mom's Turkey platter last year. Even though I've shown it to him numerous times, he accuses her of stealing other things that we don't know about. He spent about 3 weeks looking all over the house for things she "stole " when my sister, not knowing the situation, invited her over in May when I wasn't home.
I'm not going to subject them to each other.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

"Should I try to insist he get over it "?

Is that really the hill you want to die on?

Do you have a good marriage? Is he a supportive husband - other than dealing with your mother? Does he insist that YOU spend time with HIS mother?

If the answers to these questions are: Yes, yes and no - then give you husband a dispensation from spending time with mom - you go visit her in her facility, then come home and spend some "quality" time with your husband.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

Squid, another question.

Your mom's in MC. This is all she knows now. Taking her out to "join" you two could make her especially unpredictable, especially if then confronted with someone she thinks is the enemy.

Have you considered having both these events at her place? The MC? I would do this around lunchtime in the area where other seniors visit their families. It'll be peer pressure from the people she always sees to moderate her behavior toward DH. If she does blow up on DH, then he can (should) just go rather than be the focus of upset.

This would also make for letting you two have dinnertime alone without complications of behavior, let alone transport, let alone anyone feeling trapped.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report
Frances73 Nov 2021
We did that for Mom's last few holidays. We picked up prepared meals and took the food to Mom's place. It was much less stressful to her, limited the disruption to her schedule, and let us then go to our holiday events without worrying about not including her. Plus, she got bragging rights that her family visited her!
(2)
Report
I no longer have a relationship of any kind with my MIL. She has blamed me for so many things that I did not do, stealing her engagement and wedding rings just being one--and has openly spoken of her hatred of me, even in front of my kids. Horrible. Consequently, they have no relationship with her.

Dh would certainly PREFER for me to accompany me to visit his mom (still living in her own home) but I will not go. He's offered me $500 cash to go, once. I laughed it off and said I could get my OWN $500 and that was just ridiculous.

Now he goes, maybe every other month. Once in a great while she will agree to go to lunch with him, most times, it's a drop in visit and he fixes a couple things there and comes home.

He was really bummed about his latest visit and was ramping up to guilt me into going with him--and I stopped him with a "and how many times have you gone with ME to see MY mother?" The answer to that was "about 10 years". And she lives 2 miles away.

Neither of our moms have dementia, but are just slowly getting 'dotty' if that word is even really used. It's hard. They are both 92 and really pretty miserable. I am OVER the guilt I used to feel at not being able to like my MIL. I came into the family a dewy eyed 20 yo thinking I could make anyone like me.

Epic fail. I put 44 years into kowtowing to this woman and I am done.

Do I wish it had been different? Absolutely.

DH is responsible for 'gifting' his own mother for her b-day and Christmas. I imagine he'll either buy something incredibly expensive (guilt) or he'll forget. Either way, I don't/can't care.

We don't talk about our issues with the moms. There is no point.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report
Frances73 Nov 2021
LOL, Mom called her mother-in-law Mrs Jones for nearly 50 years! The nerve of her, marrying the perfect son! She was never asked to call her anything else.
(0)
Report
Mom is safe in MC. Hubby is not having to be in her general vicinity, and unless he wants to be, why SHOULD he be. Now he is down to living through these holidays,and he is willing to do this. He may be a better man than I am a woman. I can tell you right now that in a situation like this, where you have admitted that your mother has ALWAYS had little use for him, I would not be as kind as he is. I would likely be off on those holidays donating my time to a local charity where I would be loved and appreciated.
These things happen. Why would you want to insert yourself in the middle of a war, even if a minor skirmish? That would not give you the peace and joy of family gathering, it would only put you torn in the middle and hurting.
Acknowledge that Mom never cared for your hubby but YOU do. Acknowledge that your Hubby is trying best he can for the sake of a holiday and thank him. And visit your Mom in her board and care. Take her a whole mess of boxes of Christmas Cards.
Wishing you PEACE for the holidays. Life isn't always a Jimmy Steward movie. Sometimes we just have to get through them until real life shows up again.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Than you so much, everyone. I really appreciate the answers and the clear consensus here!
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

My Mom was 5 min. up the road in an AL. I just made a left out of my development and drove straight there. So, I checked in everyday. I only stayed 15 or 30 min. Mom had lost the conception of time. Sometimes I wonder if she even knew me. My DH never went with me and I didn't ask. He didn't like NHs. When she went to a NH, that was in the next town so I cut down on my visits to every other day. Basically to let staff know there was someone checking on her. Mom was in her last stage of Dementia by then.

Since DH and Mom never did get along, why do you feel the need to push him going with you? There are many posts on here where the husband is not involved in the care of the wife's parents. There are some where the wives aren't involved with in-laws care. Others, the DH expects the wife to care for his parent/s and him not being involved. Do you see Mom every day? You really don't need to. She is safe and cared for.

As long as your husband understands that some of your time needs to go to Mom, then I would just let things go. Really, what kind of "us" time can u have visiting Mom?
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Fact #1 - your husband did not take it into his head to swipe his mother in law's Christmas cards.

Fact #2 - the faulty connections in her brain, combined with a habitually suspicious personality, led to your mother's conviction - her sincerely held belief - that he did. Why? For what reason did she imagine he would even have wanted them? God knows!

That your mother no longer refers to the incident suggests that she has since accepted that he did no such thing; however, she possibly can't quite rid herself of the feeling that something happened to do with him.

Does she ask where he is? Have you formally asked her to withdraw the accusation and apologize to him?
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
Isthisrealyreal Nov 2021
Are you sure he didn't swipe the cards?

Being sarcastic, I find the idea of accusing a man of such a thing hilarious.
(3)
Report
I think for the time being, they are best separated. I dont see the point in forcing your husband to go along with you when he is clearly unwanted by the mother, and she clearly doesn't want him there either so its not a good experience for either of them. And you are just putting more stress into the situation by sandwiching yourself between their drama or insisting on them having to spend time together when that's really not necessary at all. I am sure over time, she will forget this delusion.
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

It would be best for your mother not to be aggravated in her delusions again.
She is in MC, go visit her alone for an hour on the holiday. Bring gifts.

It is not unusual for someone with Alzheimer's to pick someone in the family and falsely accuse them. Keep her away, protecting her and your husband from being hurt. If she does not see him, maybe she will forget.

You are not doing anyone any favors by enabling a meetup. Be at peace about it-it is nothing he has done, really. Put your beliefs in action: " I believe people have a right to avoid being subjected to hostility and insults."

It was so very sad when this happened to a friend's adult grandson-his gma accused him of stealing and rape-made no sense to anyone, but she picked him. He was never able to visit her again.

Can you help your own grief over this situation, and let it go? So sorry this has happened-her brain is broken. It is all new to you-no one's fault, and not your fault either! 🌸🌸
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

Accept that you'll have Thanksgiving and Christmas. Other than this, it doesn't sound like you are "fighting" to keep them apart, it's more like he's detached himself.

Now if it comes to the point of you doing too many hours so that it affects your marriage, then I'd at least listen to the complaint. I'd suggest limiting mom time to 25 percent of the shared time you have with each other, and if that's just weekends, don't upend the things he wants to do because Mom.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

Your husband obviously doesn’t like your mother, and your mother doesn’t like him. Dementia makes it worse, and to be honest spending time in a NH or MC is not most people’s choice for recreation. Being a spare wheel in your visit would be even less appealing. Your mother is getting good care, and I hope that you don’t feel any need to ‘split your free time’ equally between her and your husband.

It's good of your husband to cope with your mother for Thanksgiving and Christmas. Clearly she will pretty much dominate HIS enjoyment of them. Unless it all goes swimmingly well and the relationships blossom (sounds not likely), I’d thank him for what he is doing, and let him go and enjoy his free time in any way he wants.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report
lkdrymom Nov 2021
I have to agree. Be happy that he is willing to sacrifice his enjoyment of the holidays so you can have your mother with you.

People always say "it is the disease" as if that makes it all ok. It isn't. He doesn't have the connection you have with your mother so he doesn't have the desire to let abuse roll off his back the way you might. He is entitled to his feelings and expecting him to just get over it is not fair.
(7)
Report
See 1 more reply
I would see how it goes and decide from there how to proceed.

Unfortunately, they never got along, so that's not likely to change. Alzheimer's patients can remember the darnedest things, so she may accuse him of another transgression and keep the animosity fresh. Then again, she may be pleasant and they can share time together in the here and now with some enjoyment.

I hope it works out for the latter for your sake.
Helpful Answer (1)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter