Follow
Share

My father is extremely beloved among his friends - his peer group is comprised of people whose careers he launched and supported, and those who did likewise for him. Their relationships span about 30 years, and his gaggle of closest “favorites” dote on him with birthday get togethers and celebrations. Not anymore, though. His world is shrinking, and his mobility issues aren’t helping when it’s hard to get out and around.


Only a few people know of his currently declining health, even fewer know of his dementia. Nobody, beyond my mother and I, know how seriously bad it has gotten over the past few months. Incontinence, jumbled words, not making sense, and inability to perform habitual things like brushing teeth or, sometimes, walking.


He’s still so lovely, gracious and kind. I know we are blessed that his core personality is that of a good, nurturing person - it seems rare to have that as a default setting. ❤️


So - do you tell those whom he once loved and cherished, people who shared the same affection and admiration for him - do you tell those people WHY they never see or hear from him anymore? He’s like a father figure to some - do I have an obligation to let those closest to him know so that they can see him for what may be the last time before he disappears completely?


And what of his memory and dignity? I promised him I would always protect his dignity in failing health - but we never saw this dementia coming. We especially were NOT prepared for how quickly we’re losing him. My mother thinks it would be wrong to let people see him like this - that it would taint their memory of him. But these are people who love him, much the same way I do-something like hero-worship. (Yes, he really is THAT wonderful. No lie.) He’s made such a profound difference in their lives, so are we depriving him of something by keeping away people who want to thank him for the difference he’s made in their lives? He occasionally has glimmers of still being my dad, but also sometimes has moments where he’s very aware of all he’s lost. Would it be embarrassing for him to be seen like this? Is the risk of embarrassment worth it if there is the chance he will remember them and feel the love?


I truly have no clue. I’m helping my parents with this aging thing, so I’m living with them in what would have been a caregiver’s apartment. My parents have their relationship, and I am their child, so I defer to that primary bond. My mother has been with him for 60 years, so obviously, she knows him. But I know him in a different way, as my hero, for the past 50 years. I want to discuss it with her, but we’re both so overwhelmed by the daily declines, we’re a bit spun. And it’s not like I have a clear thought I can express b/c I have NO CLUE what is even going on with why this is happening so quickly. I thought we’d have more time. I’m hoping for some guidance from people who have experienced “coming out” with dementia. Is it a good or bad thing to do? What is the balance? Do you let them fade away as a perfect image to some people, or do you let them see him to say what is probably goodbye? All I know is that we are running out of time. I love him and want to do right by him. Always.

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Find Care & Housing
Yes. Tell them in earnest and then take it from there. They need to know the truth and hiding it from them puts doubt on your credibility.
Helpful Answer (5)
Report

Dementia is a disease every older person is familiar with, telling his friends should be no different than telling them if he had some other disease like cancer - when people inquire about him just be upfront about it.
Helpful Answer (11)
Report

You let it be known that his mental powers are failing. The tactful phrase used by some care providers for this is "mentally frail" - I like this, because it underlines the real parity between mental and physical decline. It should be no more shameful or blameworthy that he has become mentally frail than that he is physically less strong than he was, or indeed that his age goes up by one year on year.

Question 1: Should you invite a given individual? - Will your father probably enjoy this particular visitor? If yes, yes. If no, no. Don't be afraid to be selective.

Question 2: Should those who love and esteem him come to see him? Prepare them for what to expect, and try to confirm that they understand the implications. Try also to discourage explicit farewells or leave-takings - thanks and appreciation can be expressed by their talking about what they're doing now with what your father taught them. Then leave it to them: don't blame those who shy away.

I felt honoured to be allowed to visit a very dear man who by that time was barely responsive, quadriplegic and needed routine suction. It was difficult to smile and be cheerful, but on the other hand it was reassuring to see how well cared for and loved he was. If I'm really honest, I felt I was there to stand by my friend, his wife, rather than for any good my presence could do him.

But I suppose I would like to think that my visit told him people hadn't stopped loving him because he was no longer the man he'd been. Or perhaps that the loss of his abilities didn't mean he wasn't still that man. My friend was sure he knew me; I'm not, but I don't think it matters. He knew that he was important to another person in addition to his wife and children and nurses.

Don't be afraid of what people might say. If there are unfortunately some who will talk ignorant or sentimental nonsense in public, they're going to anyway. Better to tell the truth and shame the devil.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report
disgustedtoo May 2019
Agreed that:
1) you should let the others know about the situation, but you don't have to provide explicit details. Personally I knew little to nothing about dementia nor did I know anyone who "experienced" this before mom started down that path. I encounter so many now that share similar experiences, and everyone is nice and/or very understanding about it! Odds are that many of them are aware of or know someone in the same situation.
and
2) leave it up to the others to decide whether to visit or not. Some may be okay with it, others might be uncomfortable seeing the changes in your dad. It probably would be best to keep these visits one-on-one so as to not overwhelm him, but since they have known each other a long time, they are likely still in his memory somewhere! For those who make the best connections with dad, invite them back often!

Stay there with him when the visits happen, so you can assist in directing how things progress - you understand his "jumbled" words or body language best, so you can be the bridge between him and his friends.

Although mom is not in favor of this, try to convince her to give it a try at least once, choosing someone he had the best relationship with for the initial visit. Explain how much this might mean for dad - he will more than likely remember these people and enjoy their visits even if he really cannot communicate well. Mom is forgetting recent events, repeats herself often, etc, but still remembers others who she had long time relationships with and enjoyed a visit with some distant relatives from Canada last year!

Keep the visits brief, and if she can see that perhaps these brightened dad up some, she might be more accepting of future visits from others.

Also reassure HER that there is no shame in this condition. He has no control over it just like he would have no control over any other medical condition. It might mean a lot to him to see his old friends and there is only one way to find out!
(1)
Report
See 1 more reply
Personally I would keep it to his closest circle - probably those you have described as already knowing. There is nothing others can do, and unless he would benefit from seeing them and would get pleasure from it, I personally feel letting them remember him as he was is kinder to them. Let him see the people he knows and let them "retire" as they get forgotten if that is what they want. Dementia can make friends and family feel very guilty but there is no need for this, the "patient" (apologies I don't know the best term to use for people suffering this dreadful degeneration is) who has lost the knowledge is happy with what they have. I am sorry you are having to go through this especially with a quick decline in someone who has given so much pleasure to others over many years.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Dementia is very sad and heartbreaking, but it is not shameful. By hiding your father's dementia from people who admire him and have been close to him you appear to be ashamed of your father's illness as though that in someway it is his fault. It is in that way that you are taking away his dignity. You may want to share with one person in each of his circles - academic, social, etc - who is then responsible for letting the others in that circle know the situation. That will save you and your mother from constantly retelling/reliving your situation. Also lay out some ground rules - for example, your dad may appreciate cards and letters which you can read to him over and over rather than visits from people who he may at this time not even remember. There may be a few close friends that you invite to visit occasionally if you think your dad is up to it. But, please, don't be ashamed of his illness.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report
Slekker May 2019
Thank you for your thoughtful answer. Please be assured that I am in no way embarrassed by my father’s illness or blaming him for it. Both of those things couldn’t be further from my mind. I am just trying to navigate a developing situation and am too close to it to see clearly what to do.

That said, all of the responses have been incredibly helpful. Thank you for taking the time.
(0)
Report
Yes, and they probably have already figured it out on their own, or are highly suspicious of what it happening.
My mother was a professional for about thirty years before she began her decline, but she refused to give anyone contact information for me, so when I began to notice that things weren't "right", and she refused help, I had to wait until I had an opening occur.  My friends said wait for the "call" that she has had fallen, that she has set the house on fire, or that she has had a bad accident, then you will get the opening that you need.  I had to wait twenty-two years for this to occur.  People were already concerned about her, but could not reach me.  She finally set the house on fire, and that gave me the opening.  I didn't really have to "tell" anyone because they already knew.  I was able to step in legally and "took everything away" and got a shell of my mother as a reward.  She is doing better than earlier, and people who were concerned about her are kept up to date by me as to how she is doing.  I have had her for more than three years.  No one thinks that I have done the wrong thing by stepping in to help her.  They knew she needed it long before I could step in.  So did I.
Helpful Answer (6)
Report

You also might keep people informed and ask them to share fond memories and words of encouragement through a private FB page, or a caringbridge site. you could add in the email addresses of only the closest friends and start by saying something about how beloved your father is to so many and how much he has loved and admired each one included in the site. Let them know that they have probably noticed your family’s absence and wondered exactly what was going on. Say you’ve been blindsided and overwhelmed by his disease and his rapid decline. Let them know that you would love to be able to share with him their fond wishes and words of encouragement, and that if any of them would like a brief visit, that they should let you know and depending on how he is feeling/doing, you will let them know if that is possible. Tell them if they’d like to send cards, letters, pictures, you will put them together in a book for him, and for you and your mother to be able to remember and cherish the good times, and the wonderful people in your lives.
Helpful Answer (9)
Report

What makes your Mom most comfortable? Ask her. If she would feel supported through visits, then welcome only those people who will be most encouraging. This is is such a hard time for you both. Don’t say too much to your mom about who you are informing—if they don’t come, simply knowing their identity, could make your mom feel abandoned.

Visitors may may be very therapeutic for your dad. Stagger the invitations so he isn’t overwhelmed.

Take care of yourself— it is touching, rare, and wonderful to read about your love and support for your dad. He is so lucky to have you!

We all hope one day that our kids will feel the same way!
Helpful Answer (7)
Report

YES!! By all means, invite anyone who wants to stop by to do so. If they feel awkward, ask them to bring a photo or other momento of the time they spent with Dad and share a funny or touching story with him. Even if your Dad doesn’t remember the story, he’ll certainly be entertained by it. My FIL’s Alzheimer’s is very far advanced. He rarely knows who we are or where he is, but it’s very obvious that he enjoys our visits. Your Dad may not recognize the people, but I’m willing to bet he can still recognize their love and care of him. I’d also bet your Mom would benefit from some friendly, smiling faces bringing encouragement. Hugs to you and you Mom. It’s a hard road to walk.
Helpful Answer (8)
Report

These are all beautiful answers. I agree. Some of the people you are describing will be happy to have the chance to see him and say goodbye. Others won't be comfortable and won't come but might reach out in other ways. Sadly, this decline is part of life for many people. It is so sad but he may have the chance to bask in admiration and love. I think it is sadder when you read the warm thoughts people express after a person has died.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report
disgustedtoo May 2019
Perhaps leave the "goodbyes" out.... Dad likely won't understand and best not to rub it in with mom and daughter! If they are comfortable with the visit, they can be welcomed back for more visits.
(1)
Report
I can tell you that my Luz loved to have visitors even thought she could not communicate with them and after a few minutes she would just go back to watching her TV show or lay down and sleep.
By all means, invite the friends over and tell them to just talk about anything. Anything at all. I don't care what it is. Unless it upsets your LO., talk about it.
The office party of 1962, the flat tire they had. Almost anything. And take it from there.
Helpful Answer (10)
Report

Invite friends but one at a time as often large groups confuse and frighten.
I would "use" these friends to give Mom a break. Have one person come one or two days a week for an hour or two. Mom can get out and get some shopping done while Dad and friend visit.
Yes some will fall by the wayside but others will step up.
When you call to invite them over explain the situation and if it has been a while describe the decline. I would not leave the first time someone stops by just make it a short visit a cup of coffee, light lunch and a chat. If they want to visit again ask if they would feel comfortable sitting with Dad for an our or two so some errands can get done or just so Mom can have lunch with friends.
You are thoughtful protecting you dad. I think he may do well with visits. But if you do find that he is stressed make the visits shorter or stop them. Play it a day at a time.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

I personally feel that there is nothing to be embarrass about who the person had become; remember it is a disease it has nothing to do with who your father was.

Let the people choose to be or not around him, but give your father a chance to see them and enjoy others presence for could be the last time. It is the most difficult and challenging disease, we choose how to react to everything and anything that is here with us. This is the longest goodbye, we all have to deal with but given the opportunity savor every minute of it no matter how challenging it is.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

Keep it to small groups as the hussel & bussel of many people will make things worse for him - do a trial meeting with one who is the most compassionate then reassess if you feel that more should happen - limit it to twice a week for everyone's sake
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

All families and family dynamics are different and would handle this differently. I think of it as an opportunity to teach, myself. Before Robin Williams how many of us had heard of Lewy's Dementia. All that said, this is currently your Mom's decision. Your input will be of great value to her, but at present you seem to have no strong feelings everywhere. I am assuming that your Dad is no longer in any position to accept where he is, speak of it, or have an opinion? For were he then it should be HIS opinion that counts most for you all. Do you think your Dad would know, be comforted by the love and support of others he may no longer remember? If the answer is yes, then that should weigh on it also. So it is, for my mind, firstly about what would make your DAD most comfortable, and secondly about your Mom's comfort level. At some point, with the worsening so rapid, it is kinder to those who love him to explain the major ways in which he is now not the person they remember. But do educate people all you are able to, for this is one of the hidden things, and so many of us are going here.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

It really is up to your mother I suppose, but, if she believes that your father would not want to have strangers (In his mind they would be strangers) coming by to visit, then, I'd be respectful of that.

I can't know what it is to be in that situation, but, I don't think that I would want many people seeing me in a state where I am not able to chat, don't remember who they are, display obvious cognitive decline, etc. I'd prefer to be remembered as I was during most of my life and not my declined state to be the headliner. Maybe, a close friend or two, but, no more. When people ask about me, I'd hope my family members would say that she's had cognitive and physical decline and isn't up for visitors. Cards and letters are welcome.I

I know there is no shame in dementia. I'm not implying that. It's just that I don't want dementia to define me and if people see that for the last years of my life, I suspect that it would.

I understand why Nancy Reagan protected her husband the way she did. But, it's a personal choice and I'd support what your mother thinks is best.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

I don't know.  By not telling it's almost like we encourage and facilitate all the stigma/shame of it.  It took me a while to accept that mom had dementia, but now I find the words flow freely.  Her own behaviors with others made it obvious.  At 96 she has no friends really as she out survived them and even prior to the onset showed no interest in socializing much beyond the usual couples get togethers.  You might be surprised how many people you have casual contact with know and have experienced this.
Helpful Answer (4)
Report

From personal experience, I would tell them. When my Mama had a stroke, my Papa was adamant that no one see her “like this”. He was convinced she was going to fully recover, talk about denial. She, of course, didn’t recover. She continued downhill and added vascular dementia and their close friends never saw her again. That was really hurtful for them. So much so that now that Papa is a shut-in, with Parkinson’s and in his 90’s, no one will visit him. And he can’t understand why.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

This is heart aching I know. My mother is in a loving AL place close to us. I'm her legal guardian. She has cerebral atrophy. About two years she had really good long term memory. Presently very little. Short term even less. She's healthy and walks all the time. We see her condition progressing more quickly.
Loving child to your parents, indeed you are. Your father a great man.
Your father's dignity will remain intact as you continue to relate to your father as you always have. Always give him choice of decision though it looks as if you and or mother will have to decide or have final say for what's best.
Those of his circle of influence and his friends, if they ask about him, tell them. For those who desire to visit with him, be selective. Always be truthful, real and down to earth with them of his situation. No one needs to know the explicit intimate details. After you let them know, let them decide if they still want to visit.
At your father's stage he could at least be "familiar" with the visitor or could recognize them! There's the possibilty too he may not respond at all. I think he would be responsive in some way, especially to someone who has been very close to him. In any event, it can be a plus for you all and or you & mother.
Be very strict with who, when, and visitation time. And be sure to regulate quantity of visitors.
Blessings
Helpful Answer (5)
Report
SparkyY May 2019
Great advice. I found that in my mom's case it was her decision to back away from her friends. Not all of them she's still friends with a few who are smart enough to realize what was happening and loved her too much to disappear. I totally agree with you in telling them before they visit. There's nothing more heart breaking than that awkward pause when mom runs into someone she hasn't seen in while and they practically run in the opposite direction after it becomes obvious that mom isn't the same. I made sure after her latest visit to the hospital then temporary rehab that anyone I could think of that she might see knew what was going on. I was shocked by how many of the people I thought were really good friends decided not to come see her.
(3)
Report
If these people are truly his friends and care about him, be honest and tell them the truth. Then if they continue to be friends, fine - if they get upset and can't handle it then let them go - they are not worth it. Let them make the next move and time will tell who is a friend and who is not.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

Tell his friends the truth. Clearly, he has some dear friends that may want to spend some time with him. Is there anyone he asks about or that you believes he still remembers? If so, let that person(s) know. Sometimes memory from very long ago is very intact and he may enjoy talking, or just sitting with, some of his old buddies.
Helpful Answer (3)
Report

These friends may have already picked up on his changing person. If they have not, they should be told.
Helpful Answer (2)
Report

Thank you for all of these amazing responses. I was very worried my question was too long for anyone to bother with. But for those of you that did, please know you have each touched my heart so much! ❤️❤️❤️
Helpful Answer (0)
Report

This question has been closed for answers. Ask a New Question.
Ask a Question
Subscribe to
Our Newsletter